Reports claiming to know motive complicate, confuse Columbia mall coverage

WBAL, NBC reported that shooting was 'domestic,' but police say they know of no relationship

January 29, 2014|By David Zurawik | The Baltimore Sun

Another shocking crime, another case of media adding confusion rather than clarity to the coverage.

That's one of the key story lines so far in terms of coverage of the shooting at the Mall in Columbia that left three dead Saturday.

As police continued to say after more than four days of investigation that they could find no relationship between the gunman and the victims, two tweets published Saturday that said without qualification that there was a relationship demand scrutiny, as do statements made on air at WBAL.

The first published shortly after noon Saturday came from the NBC-owned and -operated station in Washington, News4 Washington.

It said: "@NBCNews' Pete Williams confirms Columbia mall shooting was a domestic situation, not random."

If the time stamp on the tweet is correct, it came at 12:03 p.m. Saturday, which would put it about 48 minutes after the shooting took place, according to the police timeline.

That is pretty remarkable -- Williams, NBC's Justice Department correspondent in Washington, confirming 48 minutes after the crime took place what the police say they still have not confirmed four days later.

But here's something even more confusing and/or remarkable: NBC News says Williams never confirmed anything publicly.

Here’s the statement sent to The Sun this week by NBC News: "A NBC spokesperson confirmed that Pete Williams never publicly reported the Maryland shooting was a domestic situation."

And here's something perhaps even more remarkable yet given that statement from NBC News, a tweet from the verified account of NBC Nightly News, the network's evening newsscast, that says: "Latest: Shooting at mall in Columbia, Maryland was a domestic situation, federal law enforcement official tells NBC News - @PeteWilliamsNBC."

This tweet is timestamped 3:07 p.m. Saturday.

Saying Pete Williams “confirms” that it was a "domestic situation" in the tweet from the NBC-owned station carries considerable authority given that Williams was the star reporter on the Boston bombings insisting at first that there was no arrest while CNN’s John King and others, citing law enforcement sources, got it wrong and said there was. Columbia Journalism Review hailed his “accurate ... ahead of the pack" reporting.

Here’s another tweet that has added to confusion in local coverage. It comes from WBAL-AM radio reporter/anchor John Patti, who was reporting for both WBAL radio and TV Saturday that the crime was domestic.

His tweet is time stamped 4:22 p.m. Saturday. It says: “Columbia Mall shooting domestic. Former boyfriend of  Zumiez clerk shot her and her new boyfriend also an employee of store”.

At about the same time Saturday, Patti also reported that information on WBAL-TV.

"I found out through my sources," he told anchors Deborah Weiner and Jason Newton, "that this is indeed a domestic incident. I found out that we're dealing with the former boyfriend of a clerk at the store who is engaged to another clerk at the store. So, if you follow this with me, it's a former boyfriend/girlfriend who broke up. The girl is now engaged to be married to a new boyfriend who also works at Zumiez. The former boyfriend went into the store with the gun today, took their lives, and then his own life."

No one else that I know of offered the “former boyfriend/girlfriend" narrative for motive -- and certainly not that kind of detail.

In response to questions about Patti's reports, WBAL News Director Michelle Butt sent the following email response this week to The Sun:

“In situations like the Mall shooting, source relationships are everything,” she wrote. “Veteran reporters like John Patti don’t go on air or into the digital space unless the source has merit. We felt we had enough credible source information to report what John’s sources were telling him. At that point, police were investigating a domestic relationship and as of now police have not yet established motive or determined whether the victims knew the gunman. While everyone continues to speculate over motive, we continue to talk with sources and work the story.”

CNN also raised the possibility that the shooting was “domestic” but attributed the motive to federal law-enforcement sources and contextualized it as a possibility -- not a "confirmed" fact.

The role that social media “reporting” plays in shredding traditional standards of verified journalism and confusing the public about what is and is not truly confirmed has been much debated in recent months among news professionals. But the issues connected with such tweets -- and sometimes the on-air reports that accompany them -- matter on a personal level as well to all citizens, especially when it comes to families of victims.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.