Grading system for Baltimore restaurants proposed

Letter grades based on health inspections would be posted in public view

October 02, 2012|By Kevin Rector, The Baltimore Sun

Restaurant and bar owners in Baltimore may soon be required to post letter grades rating their performance in city health inspections — a system aimed at informing the public about the cleanliness of neighborhood eateries.

Legislation mandating that the city health department implement a grading system and create an online database of grades is scheduled to be reviewed Wednesday by the City Council's health committee. Every member of the council and council President Bernard C. "Jack" Young have signed on as sponsors of the bill, which was introduced by Councilman Brandon Scott.

The city health department and the Baltimore Development Corporation have also thrown their support behind the measure, as have other city agencies and Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake's administration.

"Ultimately, people deserve to know the conditions of places where they eat," Scott said. "This is about people being able to make an informed choice."

Representatives of the state's restaurant industry and some local establishment owners disagree, calling the measure an expensive, inconsistent and ill-informed policy that would not benefit public health but would threaten local businesses.

Ron Furman, owner of Max's Taphouse in Fells Point for the past 26 years, said he takes pride in his business and expects he would receive a top grade. Still, he fears that he and other responsible business owners could face a major drop in sales under the grading system if, when inspected, they happen to have a minor infraction based on a one-time mistake and receive a lower grade.

"If a guy comes in from out of town and he sees a thing on the wall that says, 'Health Inspection: B,' he's going to say, 'Well let's not eat here, let's go look for an A.' And meanwhile, the place is fine," Furman said. "It could be devastating financially because the public doesn't understand."

There are more than 5,700 food establishments in the city that are inspected on a sliding scale based on level of risk, according to Mary Beth Haller, the city's assistant commissioner of environmental health. Currently, more than 2,600 "high-risk" establishments are inspected every four months; more than 1,900 "moderate-risk" establishments are inspected every six months; and more than 1,200 "low-risk" establishments are inspected every other year.

This year, 68 have been closed or temporarily closed due to violations, which range from lacking hot water to having mice or insect infestations, Haller said. There were 111 closures in 2011. The total number of closures per year has generally been trending downward since 2007, when there were 267, according to statistics Haller provided.

"We have good compliance. We want that to continue," Haller said. The grading system, she said, is "just another way of providing patrons with information."

Melvin Thompson, senior vice president of government affairs and public policy with the Restaurant Association of Maryland, which strongly opposes the grading system, called Scott's bill "a solution in search of a problem."

Thompson said one of the most concerning aspects of the bill, as written, is its lack of details.

"All this legislation really does is directs the health department to come up with that system," he said. "It's asking the City Council to approve something where they have absolutely no idea what the final product is going to look like."

Paul Goldberg, who opened Meet 27 in Charles Village last year, said the city's inspectors are "pretty rigorous" in their inspections and are vigilant in pointing out problems, regardless of how minor they are. Restaurant owners already do a good job of resolving issues immediately, he said.

A grading system, Goldberg said, would muddy the waters by indicating that there are different levels of cleanliness that are acceptable in the city.

"We think you have to be clean, end of story, and if you're not clean, you shouldn't be operating. We don't believe in a grading system," he said of himself and other owners he's talked to. "You're fit to serve food or you're not. The nuances are lost on me. To me, it's a black-and-white issue."

As written, Scott's bill would give a restaurant a week to rectify problems found in an initial inspection before it is re-evaluated and given a letter grade, but the health department has recommended amending the bill so that a letter grade could be issued on the spot.

The bill indicates the best grade would be an "A," but does not outline how many different letter grades would be issued. New York City's system issues letters from "A" to "C."

Scott contends that the grading system would help the public better understand the local restaurant industry and how it is monitored, and inform residents on how city establishments compare to one another. He said he has seen some restaurants and carryout eateries in his Northeast District receive violations, work out a quick fix, then continue to operate below the standard residents deserve.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.