Making up for lost daylight saving time

Sunday's time change can have negative impact on health, studies reveal

March 07, 2012|By Mary Carole McCauley, The Baltimore Sun

Sure, the yearly switch to daylight saving time always puts some of us into a funk and a fog.

It's true that it's harder to concentrate on writing that legal brief or counting out the correct change. It can't be denied that to the sleep-deprived, small setbacks can seem extra irritating. And, it's suddenly impossible to resist the salty bag of chips, sugary sodas and chocolate candy bar.

But can the annual spring forward on daylight saving time actually be bad for our health?

We're in the midst of National Health Awareness week, which concludes at 2 a.m. Sunday, when most of the nation will leap ahead by one hour.

Several studies have established a link between the loss of sleep caused by moving clocks forward by an hour in the second Sunday in March, and a jump in car accidents, heart attacks and workplace injuries.

The same effects have not been consistently documented for the annual autumn fall back, perhaps because our bodies are less stressed by staying up late than by awakening early.

"Since most of us no longer work in the fields, there's a debate as to whether we even need to switch to daylight saving time," said Dr. Andrea Meredith, a neuroscientist and assistant professor in the University of Maryland's School of Medicine.

"Even losing just one hour of sleep can have a major impact on our functioning."

Here's how:

•More car crashes. A study by researchers at the University of British Columbia at Vancouver analyzed Canadian traffic data between 1986 and 1995 and found an 8 percent increase in traffic accidents on the Monday after the switch to daylight saving time. A similar study published in 2001 analyzed 21 years of deadly auto collisions in the U.S. Authors Jason Varughese of Stanford University and Richard P. Allen of the Johns Hopkins University concluded: "The sleep deprivation on the Monday following the shift to daylight saving time in the spring results in a small increase in fatal accidents."

A higher risk of heart attack. Scientists have known for some time that most heart attacks occur in the early mornings, as our bodies gear up for the coming day. A Swedish study published in 2009 in the New England Journal of Medicine documented a 5 percent jump in the number of heart attacks in the three days immediately following the March time change.

An increase in the number and severity of workplace accidents. According to a study published in 2009 by a scientist at the University of Michigan, crews working in mines — a particularly high-risk profession — had almost 6 percent more injuries than average on the Monday following the change to daylight saving time, and recorded a 68 percent increase in work days that were lost as a result of being harmed on the job.

"Many of us in society are already sleep-deprived to begin with," said Dr. Ron Kramer, a neuroscientist and a regional spokesman for the Illinois-based American Academy of Sleep Medicine.

"The switch to daylight saving time is one more stressor. A young and healthy person probably won't have a heart attack or stroke when he gets up Monday to go to work. But, a patient in his 60s with a chronic underlying medical condition who forces himself to get up an hour early might."

The scientists say there are two related but distinct physical mechanisms that determine the daily cycle of alertness and dream-time: circadian rhythms and the sleep system.

Meredith said that the circadian system developed in all living beings as a survival tool, and in response to the rotation of the earth and the alternating cycles of darkness and light. Early humans needed to be awake when the animals they hunted were foraging in the open, and to sleep when their prey retreated to their caves, trees or nests for the night.

She likens these rhythms to "the guy with the megaphone telling you when to sleep and when to wake up.

"The sleep system responds to those cues," she said. "The circadian system is so important and so powerful that the sleep system can't override it, unless the person is significantly sleep-deprived."

And when these cycles become disrupted by such external factors as jet lag or the spring/fall time change, there are consequences.

According to Meredith, the problem isn't just that people are short an hour of sleep. It's that even though we're getting dressed and going to meetings, our circadian rhythms are continuing to issue standard nighttime instructions regulating our heart rates, blood pressure, metabolic levels, and the release of digestive enzymes.

"Our activities get pushed forward before our ability to perform them has made the adjustment," she said.

That explains why even those people who try to compensate for the time shift by going to bed an hour early often have trouble nodding off. The same study that looked at workplace injuries found that on the first night of daylight saving time, people give up 40 minutes of sleep on average.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.