At Pabst, nostalgia continues to propel sales. Bryan Crowley, Pabst's chief marketing officer, projects a sales increase of 30 percent for Pabst Blue Ribbon next year. And nearly 17,000 kegs of Natty Boh have been sold, according to Pabst, which expects sales to exceed 20,000 by the end of the year.
Miller said he took inspiration for his purchase from entrepreneurs like Hellendrung, and also from the success National Bohemian has had in Baltimore.
But Miller's plans face major obstacles. For starters, the relaunch comes at low point for the mainstream beer industry.
"For the first time in over 50 years, beer sales are down for the third year in a row," Steinman said. While the industry had emerged from other recessions unscathed, it has been hurt disproportionately by the latest one because of the high unemployment rate among a key beer demographic, 21- to 34-year-old men, he said.
For beer companies, the revival of "heritage brands" is one of several, let's-see-what-sticks strategies pursued to shore up their bottom line.
"This revival isn't a major effort," Steinman said. "They're not spending a ton of their money on these efforts. There's a hope that these brands have some equity left."
MillerCoors and Pabst did not disclose the cost of their relaunches. Crowley said their reboots are "calculated investments" driven by macro consumer trends.
Small entrepreneurs will have a harder time because they can't afford strong marketing and can't write off flops or underperformers, Steinman said.
"I'm not sure it's a trend that has shown replicable success," Steinman said. "The outcome on these is far from certain. It's not easy. It's going to cost some money to get [National Premium] established."
Said Johnson, "We're aware the heritage strategy has worked for some companies, but I don't know that it would work every time."
Baltimore brewer Hugh Sisson, founder of Heavy Seas Beer, fondly remembers National Premium; Heavy Seas' Classic Lager is loosely based on the original National Premium recipe. But he said Miller has his work cut out for him.
Part of National Bohemian's continued popularity over the years was its perception as a cheap beer, but at the risk of hurting its image, the historically costlier National Premium might have to cut its price in order to compete.
"There was a time when we considered all that stuff, and it just didn't make economic sense," Sisson said. "I don't know that anybody can afford to bring Premium back and afford to make it a price-point beer unless you're making it by Pabst."
Miller said he hasn't settled on a price for the new National Premium but expects that it will be between the cost of a six-pack of Natty Boh and Corona.
Another problem will be space. Though Miller wants to build a brewery at his family's old oil plant property in Easton, he will have to hire contract brewers at first, and most in the area are already at capacity. Evolution Craft Brewing Co. and Dogfish Head Ales, both based in Delaware, and Maryland's Flying Dog and Heavy Seas have told Miller they can't accommodate him.
He's talked to 20 regional brewers, including Lion Brewery in Pennsylvania, but nothing's settled yet. For now, National Premium exists only as a website, a Facebook page and a Twitter account, which Miller launched in August.
Miller's next challenge is finding the money. He estimates the relaunch cost at $125,000, most of it for marketing. To raise it, he has been selling his family's petroleum memorabilia. He'll start seeking investors when he's got a contract brewer.
He has checked one major item off the to-do list: This month, he secured what he said is an original recipe from one of the National Brewing Co.'s former brewmasters, Ray Klimovitz.
Miller doesn't know whether he'll be able to replicate the success Natty Boh's had on draft, but he hopes his beer will resonate with fans.
"I think it'll have a lot of interest with those people. And hopefully, it can trickle down from there," he said. But, his challenge is, ironically, the fleeting nostalgia trend that inspired him in the first place. "I want to make sure that they buy it again," he said. Not just as a novelty."