Are middle-aged local anchorwomen a target for downsizing?

Drilling deeper in news of Marianne Banister leaving WBAL-TV

July 29, 2011|By David Zurawik | The Baltimore Sun

The departure last week of Marianne Banister from WBAL-TV after 15 years of co-anchoring a team that always finished first or second in its time period raised big questions about the changing face of television news in Baltimore.

In the past year and half, several long-time anchors have signed off the local airwaves, including Sally Thorner at WJZ, and Mary Beth Marsden at WMAR.

By long-time, we’re talking 15 years or more of coming into Baltimore homes every night with the local news. And some of those who have left the airwaves have some very definite opinions about the changes taking place.

Banister spoke candidly with The Baltimore Sun about her departure, saying it was not her idea.

“I want to make this clear: This is not my choice,” she said. “I’m not retiring. I’m not leaving to ‘spend more time with my family.’”

According to what the 51-year-old Banister says she was told, her non-renewal was strictly a matter of dollars and cents.

“The former general manager here, Jordan Wertlieb, made this decision a few months before his move to the New York offices [of station owner Hearst], and he told me it was purely an economic decision,” she said. “They had to cut a position. Basically, my contract was the one that came up, so, in essence, I drew the short straw. … My position has fallen victim to the economy.”

But in an economy where many older workers seem to be drawing lots of short straws these days, and a society where women have traditionally drawn more than men, some readers clearly wanted issues of gender and age to be explored further.

“I smell a rat,” one reader said in a comment on my Z on TV blog in response to my first report of Banister’s situation. “Unfortunately, TV news women are cast away when they age, unlike the men. … In a year or so, when everyone has forgotten Marianne, they will hire some pretty young thing regardless of whether or not she can utter two sentences in standard English. Everyone knows. Nobody says it …”

Another wrote, “Discrimination against women employed in television media is well-documented, and I hope that this isn't the case regarding Marianne. … I often wonder why media critics still shy away from examining hiring and contract differences with female anchors, newsreaders, employees. Perhaps because many media critics still fit the middle-aged male demographic, and they see women on air which automatically means there are no problems, right?”

The situation is not nearly as cut-and-dried as such comments might suggest, according to analysts and some of the anchorwomen who have lived the reality of being female and middleaged in a Baltimore TV newsroom during these turbulent media times. All of them stressed the ways in which massive changes in technology, audience lifestyle and economics challenge conventional beliefs about the way media operate. Gender and age matter, but in the end, not as much as money, they say. And money matters more than ever.

“It’s a sign of the times, you have a target on your back if you have a big salary these days,” says Thorner, who left WJZ in 2009 at what she and station general manager Jay Newman characterize as her own choosing, stressing that she was in the middle of a long-term contract when she resigned.

“I don’t think it’s happening more to women,” Thorner adds. “Marianne Banister looks great. Mary Beth Marsden looked great. … Look, I have my antennae up for that [gender discrimination], and I have to say I don’t think that’s what’s going on. … No, the answer is no — no, no, no, no, no. It’s budgets. It’s dollars and cents.”

Marsden, who recently launched a website,, which shares stories of children with autism spectrum disorders, also sees Banister as a victim of larger structural and economic change throughout the industry. But she does believe that gender and age playing a secondary role.

“The whole industry is changing, and everyone from primary anchors to reporters realizes this, and I don’t think anyone will be blindsided in this day and age when their contract is not renewed,” says Marsden, who characterized her departure from WMAR in 2009 as a “mutual decision.”

“This [Banister’s non-renewal] is just symptomatic of what’s happening industry-wide,” she adds. “Do I believe that woman was terminated because she’s a woman? No. I haven’t found that to be prevalent. But I do believe that a fortysomething or fiftysomething woman probably has a harder time getting rehired than a fortysomething or fiftysomething man. I think it’s harder for her to find that second chapter on TV.”

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.