Should the Giants bring back Burress?

July 28, 2011

Win-win for Giants?

Ron Fritz

Baltimore Sun

Some team is going to give Plaxico Burress a second (or is it third?) chance, so why not the Giants?

The wide receiver certainly owes the team after spending 20 months in prison and missing the last two seasons. He is on probation for two years on the gun charge stemming from the Manhattan nightclub incident in which he shot himself in the leg. After being released from prison in early June he has reportedly spoken to kids about the dangers of guns. If he can use a return to New York as a platform to continue those warnings to kids, so much the better.

Burress will have to be on his best behavior, so he could resurrect his career. If it's with the Giants, could be a win-win situation for both.

It's a very risky move

Dan Pompei

Chicago Tribune

There is only one way the Giants should be interested in Plaxico Burress, and that is if they can get him completely on their terms.

That means if Plax steps out of line, they should be able to cut him without much consequence. That means they should not have to pay very much for him. Remember, when the Eagles first signed Michael Vick, it was a deal that carried minimal risk for the team.

With Burress' history, his age and his layoff, he is an unknown. If Burress has learned a lesson about how he behaves, and if he still can play, he can be a great acquisition. But those are big, big ifs.

Just asking for trouble

Paul Doyle

Hartford Courant

We love stories of redemption, the happy ending when the troubled athlete puts his life back on track. And we'd love nothing more than to see Plaxico Burress step into the role by resuming his NFL career.

But he shouldn't be doing it in a Giants uniform. Sorry, but this is just a bad idea, and both sides are asking for trouble.

Burress was a problem for Tom Coughlin long before the gun incident that sent him to prison. Just last month Burress said in an interview with ESPN that he didn't like going to work for Coughlin and that he wants to go somewhere "refreshing."

Go somewhere refreshing, Plax. And go find another receiver, Mr. Coughlin. It's time to move on.

For Manning's sake, yes

Sam Farmer

Los Angeles Times

As long as Plaxico Burress and Tom Coughlin can work through their personality differences — and they're significant — the Giants should re-sign Burress. Eli Manning certainly has to be pushing for it, as Burress always seemed to be his safety valve.

Yes, there was the gun incident. For the most part, however, any trouble Burress got into in New York had to do with things that clashed with Coughlin's personality. Plaxico was a little too candid in his comments and didn't seem to understand how doing something like wearing the wrong color socks on game day might rub people the wrong way.

Does he deserve a second chance in his career? Yes. Should that be in New York? Why not?

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.