AFSCME and the administration argued that because collective bargaining units are required to represent both members and nonmembers in contract negotiations and individual grievances, it is only fair that all employees pay.
But one union, the Maryland Classified Employees Association, opposed the bill. Critics argued that the legislation would force payroll deductions on employees who choose not to be part of the unions. It also could diminish the union's membership, as some might drop out so they wouldn't have to pay both dues and the fee.
"It's going to be goodbye to every other union, and we're going to end up with a monopoly," said Del. Steve Schuh, an Anne Arundel County Republican.
