Warranty works on front-end shake


August 03, 2008|By DAN THANH DANG

Bradley Joyce was preparing for grave disappointment.

Shortly after purchasing an $8,724 Thruxton motorcycle from Clinton Cycles in Camp Springs, the geographic information systems manager said he felt "a significant and dangerous feeling wobble" in the bike at speeds over 45 miles per hour.

Several attempts to fix the wobble got him nowhere. He was without his bike for more than a month. Joyce feared that his journey into warranty hell would only lead to no good and an eventual lemon law claim.

Warranties make my head hurt. In most cases that end up here, companies flub the job and tick off the customer. Loopholes in the law, or the lack of any law, further fail consumers. But Clinton Cycles and manufacturer Triumph USA proved Joyce wrong, and Maryland law would have protected him had the situation gone terribly awry.

Excuse my joy. It's not every day I get good consumer news like that, especially after several bleak moments for Joyce.

The Baltimore resident's problem started on July 21 when he took his bike into Pete's Cycles in Fullerton, an authorized Triumph dealer, for a 500-mile initial inspection. Joyce asked the service department to take a closer look for a shake in the front end.

"They balanced the front wheel," said Joyce, who paid $260 for the service visit. "It didn't help."

Joyce called Pete's back to tell them the fix didn't work. They put him on a waiting list. A call back to the original dealer that sold him the bike, Clinton, got Joyce an appointment right away.

On June 28, Joyce dropped the bike off and Clinton diagnosed the problems as "a head bearing in need of adjustment." They tightened it. Joyce started to take the bike home - and turned back around. "The problem was still there," he said.

On July 3, he called Clinton to check on the bike's progress. No one had looked at it yet. That evening, the dealership called to say it swapped the wheel out, but the problem persisted. So Clinton did a complete head bearing replacement under warranty.

The wobble won the day.

On the fifth attempt, even as Joyce's patience was worn microscopically thin, Clinton disassembled the fork tubes, which deal with the front-end suspension and how the bike handles. And still, wobble - 5, Clinton - 0.

At wit's end, Joyce wrote a letter to Triumph's head of customer relations, Peter Carleo. He ended the e-mail by saying that if the problem was not resolved, "I intend to turn the matter over to the state lemon laws."

Lemon laws are great if your vehicle is protected. Not all lemon laws are equal, though. Depending on which state you live in, motorcycles and recreational vehicles may not qualify.

"Most people think they are automatically covered," said Ronald Burdge, an Ohio attorney who specializes in lemon laws. "The amount of lemon law coverage you have might depend on the number of wheels you have. Four wheels? You're probably covered. Three? Probably not. Two wheels, it's 50-50. A lot of states don't cover motorcycles. It makes no logical sense."

The beauty of state lemon laws is that most clearly define what qualifies your vehicle, such as how long and how many times the vehicle needs repair work for the same problem, or specific problems. If you live in a state where your motorcycle or RV doesn't qualify, there is a federal consumer law that could provide some protection, but the presumptions aren't clearly defined.

Luckily for Joyce, Maryland's law does protect motorcycles (but not RVs). Under our law, four unsuccessful repairs or 30 calendar days out of service or one unsuccessful repair of a braking or steering system within 15 months or 15,000 miles allows a lemon law claim.

But here's the even better part of this story.

On the sixth and final attempt, Clinton was set to replace the entire front end of the bike. The dealership called in its master mechanic, who decided to swap out the front wheel one more time.

The wobble vanished, and so did Joyce's consternation - especially when Clinton charged him nothing for any of the 36 hours of work or parts, which would have cost thousands under normal circumstances.

"Ultimately, the people down at Clinton Cycles worked very hard to get my problem fixed," Joyce said. "The bike rides perfectly now."

There are a number of really good lessons here.

*Check that your state lemon law covers what you're buying. If it doesn't, see if a neighboring state has a stronger law that protects nonresidents and consider buying your motorcycle, RV or disability van (which is afforded even fewer protections) from there.

*Deal with the dealer you originally bought your vehicle from, so that your problems are a priority to them.

*Stay on top of the problem. Joyce never let his concern go for more than a week without checking in with Clinton, and he was always politely persistent.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.