Misconduct irks city prosecutor

2 veteran officers disciplined over alleged lying in reports

July 01, 2008|By Melissa Harris | Melissa Harris,Sun reporter

It was a painful moment for Baltimore's chief narcotics prosecutor when he recently dismissed drug-dealing charges against three men and said in court that they were not guilty.

Assistant State's Attorney Antonio Gioia later said the case was tainted by dishonest police work by two veteran police officers, who he believes lied in court documents to justify the arrests, and at least two others.

Concerned that the Baltimore Police Department was slow to act, Gioia and his team of prosecutors launched their own investigation into Detective Deryl Turner and Sgt. Allen Adkins.

He said the investigation uncovered enough evidence of wrongdoing to ban the officers from testifying in court, and prosecutors are now dropping all cases in which their testimony is crucial to winning a conviction.

"After my review of the investigation, it is my conclusion that their credibility and integrity have been irrevocably compromised," State's Attorney Patricia C. Jessamy wrote in an April 7 letter to Police Commissioner Frederick H. Bealefeld III.

Gioia's investigation bypassed the way police misconduct allegations are typically handled, through the department's internal investigations division and the state's attorney's police misconduct division.

Police officials refused to comment, but the effect of the prosecutor's unusual probe is that Adkins and Turner were transferred from an aggressive drug-fighting unit to one in which their chances of being needed as witnesses are minimal.

Gioia said the officers found cocaine hidden under a second-floor vent in one of the suspect's homes, but that the search was done without a warrant and thus was illegal. To make the arrests of Lloyd and Clement Bharrat and Sam Woods pass muster, the officers falsely wrote that they saw them participate in a street-level drug deal and found the narcotics hidden near a fence, Gioia said.

"My posture is one and done," Gioia said of lying. "I'm not going to tolerate any police misconduct in the performance of law enforcement duties. The ends simply do not justify the means."

A former defense lawyer for 16 years, Gioia has made investigations that have resulted in two other officers being put on Jessamy's "do not call" list of police witnesses, though he says he does not investigate all complaints. He said he chose to pursue Adkins and Turner after allegations mounted, and defense attorneys in two cases presented him with videotape evidence that appeared to back up their allegations.

From there, in his free time and on weekends, Gioia, 52, and his team began to build a case, visiting crime scenes, securing additional photographic evidence and interviewing other police officers, witnesses and the defendants making the allegations, their defense attorneys said.

Paul Blair, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 3, the union that represents city officers, declined to comment on Adkins and Turner, but he said punishing officers this way was unfair.

"I'm sorry to say, but I've been told by our counsel that [Jessamy] has the right to say to Officer A or B, 'I'm not going to bring any of your cases forward,' " Blair said. "The problem the union has with it is that there's a difference if an officer has been convicted of something. For her then to say, because of his conviction, she's doing this, that's one thing. But officers have [been banned from testifying] who have been cleared by internal affairs and have no civil or criminal charges pending."

Both officers declined to comment for this article. Blair, of the police union, said he doubted allegations against officers who have never been criminally charged.

"One thing that gets you fired quickly is when you're charged with making a false statement," Blair said. "If they can prove officers outright lied and perjured themselves, then fire them. People can make accusations, but unless they're convicted, then should they not be presumed innocent? Everybody believes we're guilty until proven innocent."

But Gioia said that police should be held to a higher standard than civilians.

"Proof beyond a reasonable doubt shouldn't be the standard of proof for police," he said. "I would be derelict in my responsibility if I took no action when I had what I believed was substantial evidence of misconduct that may or may not arise to proof beyond a reasonable doubt."

Adkins and Turner arrested the Bharrat brothers and Woods shortly before midnight Sept. 18.

Turner wrote in charging documents that he watched Clement Bharrat, 21, cross the 1400 block of Ramsay St. in Southwest Baltimore, remove a blue bag from his jacket, hide it by a fence and return to the other side of the street. After "several more minutes" passed, a man and a woman approached the brothers and Woods. Lloyd Bharrat, 22, took their money, and Woods, 22, crossed the street, retrieved "items" from the blue bag, and returned to make the exchange, Turner wrote.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.