Health Care Crisis

Costs are up, Coverage is down. And politicians don't agree on the answers.

October 28, 2007|By Larry Williams | Larry Williams,Ideas Editor

The debate now raging over how much money the federal government should spend to provide basic health insurance for poor children is just an opening skirmish in what is likely to be an all-out war in coming months and years over how to pay for health care in America.

Almost every presidential candidate in both parties has come up with some proposal that promises to control the costs, broaden the availability and upgrade the quality of health care. At the same time, a growing number of states and localities -- including Howard County and the state of Maryland -- are seeking local answers to the problem.

Health care is in the spotlight for an array of reasons -- a growing proportion of Americans have no health insurance, costs of providing care are rising far faster than the overall rate of inflation, costs to workers of employer-provided insurance are growing while benefits are limited and the costs of coping with catastrophic illness are placing a growing burden on families and communities.

The challenge is finding ways to provide every American with quality affordable health care without dictating how the care will be offered.

Our failure to make progress toward that goal is causing a slow-motion health care crisis that is already threatening the well-being of millions.

In most other developed countries the government offers universal care with more private care choices available to those who can afford them. But many Americans fear the bureaucratic implications of a publicly funded universal care system that might provide mediocre or inadequate care. They say they want the right to choose their own doctors and methods of care.

But, truth be told, a growing proportion of Americans are losing their access to health care choice and seek care only in emergencies. The costs of providing that emergency care are extraordinarily high and the benefits are limited.

Employer-provided insurance, the bedrock of health insurance, is eroding.

About one in six people in the United States -- 46.6 million people -- lacked health insurance for all of 2005 and the ranks of the uninsured are growing with every passing year.

Many companies, particularly smaller firms, faced with fast-rising health insurance expenses are asking workers to cover some of the cost, are limiting benefits or dropping insurance plans altogether. Thirty-nine percent of firms in the United States didn't offer health insurance at all in 2006 and 41.9 percent of "wage and salary" workers aged 18 to 64 were not offered health coverage through their own employers.

Americans worry about health coverage and health care costs. For instance, 54 percent of those polled by the Pew Research Center in 2006 said that paying for the cost of a major illness is a major problem. Some 44 percent said paying for prescription drugs is a major problem.

At the same time, many are not convinced that being uninsured is a problem. A majority in a national poll taken in 2004 mistakenly believed that the uninsured can receive the care they need through clinics and hospital emergency departments.

In fact, lacking health insurance can be seriously dangerous to your health, studies by the National Academy of Sciences' Institute of Medicine (IOM) show.

According to the IOM, an estimated 18,000 adults die each year because they are uninsured and can't get appropriate health care. Hospitalized patients without health insurance receive fewer needed services and lower-quality care, and have a greater risk of dying in the hospital or shortly after discharge than patients with insurance. Uninsured victims with trauma due to an auto crash are 37 percent more likely to die of their injuries.

Uninsured children are five times more likely to have an unmet dental need and about half as likely to get needed mental health care or counseling.

And there's a good chance that at some point an uninsured person or family will face serious, economically destabilizing medical expense. Six out of 10 uninsured working-age adults report problems paying medical bills, compared with 35 percent of insured adults. Among those reporting medical bill problems, 27 percent said they struggled to pay for expenses such as food, rent and heat.

Still, a significant number of workers are balking at the rising costs of employer-sponsored insurance. Premiums for a family of four paid for by workers increased almost 12 percent between 2004 and 2005 -- from $222 a month to $248. Almost two out of three workers who chose not to participate in their employer's health plan in 2002 said the plan was too costly.

Employer-paid health care for retired workers has declined significantly in recent decades, a development that has prompted a growing number of older workers to stay on the job years beyond their original plan. Overall, 35 percent of companies with 200 or more workers offered retiree health benefits in 2006, down substantially from 66 percent in 1988.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.