Palestinians shut out of the West Bank

Scores are separated from families after Israel tightens re-entry rules

October 22, 2006|By Ken Ellingwood | Ken Ellingwood,Los Angeles Times

RAMALLAH, West Bank -- Abdelhakeem Itayem, a Palestinian with American citizenship, was counting on a simple overnight stay when he traveled from the West Bank to Jordan on a business trip.

Six months later, he is still there, trapped in bureaucratic limbo.

Israeli officials, who control the border between Jordan and the West Bank, refused to let him return when he presented his U.S. passport at the crossing.

"I came to Amman for one day. I had one suit and a change of clothes for one day. And now I can't go back," Itayem said by phone from Amman, where he has rented an apartment while awaiting an answer.

Itayem, 41, said the long delay has kept him away from his wife, Lisa, and their seven children, who remain in the family's home near Ramallah. It has also cost him his job as a manager for a Palestinian distributor of foreign consumer goods. "It's breaking my heart," he said.

Activists say scores of Palestinians who carry foreign passports, mostly American, have been denied entry this year after Israel moved to close a loophole that once allowed residents to enter repeatedly on renewable Israeli tourist visas.

The policy has created a quandary for the Palestinian Americans who remain: If they leave to get a new three-month stamp, they might not be allowed back. If they stay, their current Israeli visas will expire. Many say their past applications for formal residency in the Palestinian territories were rejected by Israel or never acted upon.

"The Israelis are turning their back to any logic," said Adel Samara, whose wife, Enayeh, was refused entry in May after she crossed to Jordan to get her American passport stamped with a fresh Israeli tourist visa.

Samara, a Palestinian economist and writer, said Enayeh, 56, is staying with a sister in Chicago after living in the West Bank for 31 years on a succession of short-term Israeli visas. Making matters worse, he said, Israel won't let him leave because of his past involvement in nationalist Palestinian groups.

"I can't go outside, and she can't come inside," said Samara, 62, sitting in his wife's Ramallah beauty parlor, which he has largely dismantled after concluding that she will have to start over if allowed back. "It is like a form of divorce."

Israeli officials say the tourist visas were not meant to serve as documents for Palestinian residency or work in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The new rules have created uncertainty and anger among Palestinian Americans, especially in the West Bank, where they number at least 30,000 and are leading players in business and academic life.

A group of Palestinians with American citizenship has lobbied diplomats and launched a campaign to draw attention to the problem. Samara, who is also a U.S. citizen, is working with an Israeli advocacy group to challenge the legality of the new rules.

He and others charge that Israel imposed the tighter rules to punish Palestinians for electing Hamas in January's parliamentary election and to reduce the Palestinian population of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Israel rejects those claims.

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice raised the visa issue in meetings with Israeli officials in Jerusalem this month. American diplomats say they have asked Israel to explain the policy.

Israel concedes that the new rules, overseen by the Interior Ministry, have caused problems. Officials said the change was an attempt to curb misuse of tourist visas, which had become a favored means of entry for thousands of Palestinians with foreign citizenship.

"It was decided in the government, at a medium-level bureaucratic level, that this is wrong. How can you let people be here when they are obviously not tourists? It's an abuse of the tourist visa," said Mark Regev, spokesman for the Foreign Ministry.

But Regev said the tightened policy is having "unintended consequences" that officials were trying to correct.

Israel has said that Palestinians in the West Bank should apply for local residency, which is granted by Israel, rather than remain on a succession of tourist visas. But many Palestinians complain that they have been denied residency or have met with inaction.

After the signing of the Oslo accords in the early 1990s, Israel agreed to allow 3,000 people to move into the West Bank and Gaza Strip each year, an annual quota later raised to 10,000 and then 20,000, said Shlomo Dror, spokesman for the office that acts as liaison to the Palestinians.

But he said the Palestinian Authority, created in 1994, often failed to provide the names of those who were living in the Palestinian territories and in need of formal residency.

Israel has frozen applications aimed at unifying families since the outbreak of violence in 2000. And since Hamas won Palestinian elections in January, Israel has refused to deal with the Palestinian government because it classifies Hamas as a terrorist group.

Dror said the number of people without proper residency has grown to 60,000, in part because of Israel's freeze on the family-reunification process. "We are trying to sort the problem out and find a different way," he said.

Itayem, who was born in the West Bank but moved to Chicago at 15, said he may relocate his wife and children to Amman when school breaks for winter.

The episode has left Itayem angry and disoriented. He found work in Amman for a sister company of his former West Bank employer, the Unipal General Trading Co. But Itayem is staying in an empty apartment and without clear answers on why he cannot go back to the West Bank, his home for the past 12 years.

"What kind of a life?" he asked. "My wife is in one country, and I'm alone in another country."

Ken Ellingwood writes for the Los Angeles Times.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.