FEMA assistance abuses are found

Disaster aid payments linked to politics


FORT LAUDERDALE, FLA. — FORT LAUDERDALE, FLA.: Assistance designed to help those struck by disaster has also become a tool for politicians to bring home prized federal dollars and a windfall to residents in some of the nation's poorest communities.

In between are privately contracted damage inspectors with little incentive to safeguard the public purse.

The system is fueled by an unlimited budget - if the money runs out, the Federal Emergency Management Agency returns to Congress for more.

Everyone benefits, a South Florida Sun-Sentinel investigation found, except taxpayers footing the bill.

In the name of helping disaster victims, FEMA over five years awarded at least $330 million in areas with little or no damage, the newspaper found. While aid has legitimately flowed to thousands of people who lost their homes or belongings to fires, floods and hurricanes, thousands more have abused the system.

Outrage over $31 million to residents of Miami-Dade, Fla., last year for a hurricane that missed the county called national attention to fraud and waste in FEMA assistance. But the problem has evolved over years in cities across the country, the newspaper found.

It all starts with the federal disaster declaration, the first step to start the money flowing - a process heavily influenced by politics.

Once disaster strikes, however small, politicians from mayors to governors to members of Congress pressure FEMA for a declaration and then boast about bringing money home.

By law, federal aid is meant for major disasters that overwhelm state and local governments. Officials are supposed to prove a need for help through "damage assessments," the backbone of formal requests from governors to the president.

But the Sun-Sentinel found those assessments are not always done. Even when they are, they're sometimes not an accurate reflection of reality.

In New Hanover County, N.C., several residents whose names appear on assessments used to support disaster declarations for Hurricane Isabel in 2003 told the newspaper they suffered no damage to their homes.

In Ohio's Summit County, Emergency Management Coordinator Annette Petranic said her office has been pressured by the governor's staff and members of Congress to "try again" when initial counts failed to turn up enough damage for a declaration.

Politicians then tout their role in getting the money.

"This summer, Gov. [Jim] Doyle was successful in obtaining federal disaster aid for storm victims and local communities in 44 Wisconsin counties," a December 2004 state news release said. "This was the greatest number of declared counties in one summer since 1993."

Russell Sobel, a West Virginia University professor, has researched how closely disasters and politics are intertwined.

Sobel co-authored a 2003 study that found states politically important to a president have higher rates of disaster declaration.

Last year in Florida, President Bush declared Miami-Dade and other counties a disaster for Hurricane Frances before the storm had passed through the state.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.