Complaints on NYC subway searches grow

Some oppose intrusion as unconstitutional

others want profiling of Muslims

August 14, 2005|By Josh Getlin | Josh Getlin,LOS ANGELES TIMES

NEW YORK - As subway riders poured into Pennsylvania Station, a police officer stopped Ahmed Mohammed and asked him to open his backpack. The Pakistani-born engineer, who was visiting New York with his family, shrugged and agreed to the search.

He looked embarrassed as the officer quickly examined its contents - T-shirts and presents purchased at Macy's - and then waved him through the turnstile.

Heading for the rush hour train, Mohammed was angry.

"We all want to feel safe, after what happened in London," the 29-year-old tourist said. "And police have to do their job. But they picked me out of the crowd just because of the way I look. Not because of anything I have done."

Objections grow vocal

When police began screening subway riders last month, many New Yorkers accepted it as necessary. During the first few days, hundreds of commuters came up to officers and opened their bags for inspection, prompting reminders from top brass that the searches had to be done randomly.

Law enforcement has stressed that the policy is not targeting any particular group.

But passenger complaints like Mohammed's are becoming more frequent, and critics are becoming more vocal.

Some call the searches an unacceptable intrusion into personal freedom. Others believe that the police should be allowed to openly focus on Muslim commuters.

"It may take you a little longer to get where you're going," said New York Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, who announced the program July 21, hours after the attempted subway bombings in London. "But we're going to make sure you get there safely."

Acknowledging that the searches would be intrusive, Bloomberg said: "We live in a world, sadly, where these kinds of security measures are necessary."

New York, home to the nation's largest mass transit system, is the only big city to adopt such a program. Teams of officers set up tables in front of subway turnstiles, near signs announcing that backpacks are subject to inspection. If riders do not wish to be searched, they are free to leave the station.

Police guidelines

Guidelines call for police to search the bags of every 10th person getting onto the subway; the officers are legally barred from singling out people based on race, religion or ethnicity.

Thousands of people have been screened, and there have been no arrests. The program will continue indefinitely, Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said.

"I don't have a problem if they want to look into my bag," said Jeannie Wong, who was asked to hand over her purse at Pennsylvania Station as hundreds of commuters rushed by. "What they're doing is OK."

But on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, home to one of New York City's largest Muslim populations, there is a wariness that police may wind up engaging in profiling.

"I ride the subway every day, and this [a search] has never happened to me," said Ahmed Larby, who owns an herbal shop on the street dotted with Middle-Eastern groceries, bookshops, clothing boutiques, spice dealers and restaurants.

"In this neighborhood we support all they do to fight terrorism," he added. "But if they single out Muslims just because of who we are, that would be unfair to us all."

This month, the New York Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit demanding that the city halt its subway searches.

"This program is unprecedented, unproductive and unconstitutional," said NYCLU chief Donna Lieberman at a Manhattan news conference.

"Thousands of innocent New Yorkers are now required to allow police to rifle through their personal belongings, like birth control pills, cigarettes, diaries and other items," she said. "And none of them are suspected of doing anything wrong."

During a recent 30-minute stretch at Pennsylvania Station, police inspected the bags of elderly white men and women, middle-aged Asians, white and black teenagers, and three men who later identified themselves as Muslims.

Some critics say the diversity of commuters searched is a nod toward political correctness that ignores the reality of terrorism. They note that most of the people carrying out terrorist attacks are Muslim, and believe police should be focusing on such groups.

Dov Hikind, a Brooklyn assemblyman, held up photos of Muslim men at a news conference last week and said: "The individuals involved [in terrorism] basically look like this. Why must police think twice before examining people of a particular group?"

Hikind said he planned to introduce legislation that would allow police to focus on Muslims in subway searches. He was joined by James Oddo, a New York City councilman from Staten Island, who promised to introduce a similar bill in the council.

"There is a particular group who engage in these [terror] activities," Oddo told New York 1, a cable television news station. "They're not skinny balding Italian Americans from Staten Island."

The Los Angeles Times is a Tribune Publishing newspaper.

Baltimore Sun Articles
|
|
|
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.