Maytag's board shifts its support to Whirlpool bid

Bigger deal for $1.7 billion faces regulatory hurdle

August 13, 2005|By James P. Miller | James P. Miller,CHICAGO TRIBUNE

CHICAGO - Maytag Corp.'s board, reversing its earlier stance, declared Whirlpool Corp.'s risky but richer $21-a-share buyout proposal to be superior to the $14-a-share bid that Maytag earlier accepted from a private investment group.

The Newton, Iowa, company's move late yesterday appears to put Whirlpool's $1.7 billion bid in the lead as the fight over Maytag moves into its final stage. But Whirlpool hasn't won yet.

The contest for Maytag began in May, when an investor group led by the New York leveraged-buyout group Ripplewood Holdings offered to buy the company for $14 a share, or $1.11 billion.

Maytag's board accepted the bid, scheduled a shareholder vote and urged shareholders to vote in favor of the Ripplewood transaction.

Then things grew more complicated.

As part of the accord with Ripplewood, Maytag had permission to seek higher bids for 30 days. During that time, Maytag officials and investment bankers contacted three dozen potential buyers, but found no takers.

Maytag had never contacted the appliance industry leader, Whirlpool, however. Federal regulators routinely review corporate mergers to make sure marketplace competition won't be damaged, and Maytag executives apparently assumed a combination of the nation's No. 1 and No. 3 appliance companies would never pass regulatory muster.

Despite the snub, Whirlpool launched an ardent pursuit of Maytag. When its $17-a-share bid was rebuffed, the Benton Harbor, Mich., company raised its tentative bid to $18, then to $20 a share, and finally on Monday boosted the offer price to $21, or $1.7 billion.

Even as Whirlpool bid higher and higher, however, Maytag's board continued to stick to its recommendation that Maytag stockholders vote in favor of the Ripplewood offer. (To be sure, the probability that the stockholders would follow the directors' advice and vote to settle for $14 grew smaller every time Whirlpool raised the ante.)

But after the market's close yesterday, Maytag disclosed that directors had determined it would be "inconsistent" with their fiduciary duty to stockholders to continue backing the New York group's offer.

Stockholders must still vote the $14-a-share measure up or down, but the board "now recommends a vote against" the Ripplewood deal, the Iowa company said. Maytag also pushed the date of the vote back to Aug. 30 from Aug. 19.

Even though Whirlpool's bid tops Ripplewood's by a whopping 50 percent, there had been a real question as to whether Maytag's board would approve it. That's because it's far from certain that the government will sign off on the deal. If the regulators do block the transaction, Whirlpool has agreed to pay Maytag $120 million in a "reverse breakup fee" to compensate the target company.

Critics, however, say $120 million won't cover the damage: Maytag's financial health, they contend, is eroding so fast that the company may not be viable as an independent entity months from now, when the Federal Trade Commission completes its review.

The Chicago Tribune is a Tribune Publishing newspaper.

Baltimore Sun Articles
|
|
|
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.