Rebounding on reality TV

March 11, 2005|By Clarence Page

WASHINGTON - Who says there are "no second acts in American lives"? Well OK, F. Scott Fitzgerald did. But he didn't know about so-called reality television shows.

In recent months, we have seen has-been pop stars as diverse as Erik Estrada, Flava Flav, Tammy Faye Bakker Messner and Vanilla Ice re-emerge in the unblinking eye of roving mini-cams.

Now watch for Martha Stewart, fresh from a prison release that received more coverage than any since South Africa's Nelson Mandela ended 27 years of political imprisonment in 1989. She's set to star in not one but two TV shows.

One is to be a spruced-up revival with studio guests of the daily homemaking show she had before she turned herself in to serve five months behind bars for lying about a stock sale. The other show is a customized version of NBC's The Apprentice, hosted by Donald Trump, the billionaire developer who has made as lucrative a career out of being "The Donald" as Ms. Stewart has made out of being "Martha."

All of which, in the wake of other recent celebrity comebacks-by-media, raises intriguing questions about how smoothly today's spin industry can put a positive twist on criminal convictions and other setbacks that we used to call public disgrace.

For example, Ms. Stewart looks as saintly as Joan of Arc in the wake of her fellow blond ex-jailbird Lizzie Grubman, the New York City public relations world's answer to Paris Hilton.

Dubbed a "Power Girl" on the cover of New York magazine, Ms. Grubman is best known for throwing what the entertainment press calls "fabulous parties" for celebrity clients such as Britney Spears, Gloria Estefan, Quincy Jones and rappers with such colorful names as Jay-Z, Ja Rule and Wu-Tang Clan.

Ms. Grubman seemed to have thrown it all away in the summer of 2001 when she backed her Mercedes sport utility vehicle into a crowd outside a Southampton nightclub during an ugly hissy fit - injuring 16 bystanders.

She eventually served slightly more than half of a 60-day jail sentence before returning to freedom, beaming with contrition.

Now her reality show, PoweR Girls, made its debut last night on MTV. It follows Ms. Grubman and four protegM-ies through the day-to-day chores of making famous people more famous. Hey, if anyone is a walking billboard for such skills, it is Ms. Grubman.

In a world that seems to turn fame into its own reward, regardless of how one became famous, no bad deed, once punished, need go unrewarded.

In fact, one wonders, should Michael Jackson stop defending himself and look to a future of, say, playing himself on a cable TV network?

Could an O. J. Simpson Show have potential?

No wonder Martha Stewart decided to serve her prison sentence even while continuing her appeal of her conviction. In this case, her humility was more than a legal or moral choice. It was a smart business decision.

After overdosing on exotic excuses by celebrity wrongdoers, it was downright refreshing for many of us to see Ms. Stewart check into the slammer despite having enough wealth to keep up a big fight. Wall Street rewarded her decision by pushing her company's stock price to three times the level it was when she was convicted last March, even though experts say its fiscal outlook remains uncertain.

Americans believe in second chances for those who deserve to have one. Now Martha Stewart has hers.

In Ms. Stewart's trademark phrase, that's a good thing.

As for how good her new TV shows will be, the jury is still out.

Clarence Page is a columnist for the Chicago Tribune, a Tribune Publishing newspaper. His column appears Tuesdays and Fridays in The Sun.

Baltimore Sun Articles
|
|
|
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.