Aberdeen seen winning permission to tap creek

Philbrick favors granting access to drinking water

December 12, 2004|By Josh Mitchell | Josh Mitchell,SUN STAFF

The state's top environmental official predicted that it is a matter of time until the city of Aberdeen wins its fight to tap into Deer Creek for its drinking water, a debate the official characterized as solid science vs. environmental emotionalism.

"We're going to make our decision here based on science and not on feelings," said State Secretary of the Environment Kendl P. Philbrick.

"Science supports that Aberdeen's plan will have no adverse impact on the stream. I'm optimistic that my fellow commissioners will see it my way," he said.

Philbrick said he will vote against a coalition of environmentalists and farmers when Aberdeen's request comes before the Susquehanna River Basin Commission early next year.

He is not only a member of the commission, but also oversees the Maryland Department of the Environment, which has approved Aberdeen's request.

The river basin commission was scheduled to vote on the Aberdeen plan Tuesday, but the vote was postponed because an advertisement of the meeting never ran in a local newspaper, Philbrick said.

Commission bylaws require the public be notified 20 days before a critical vote, he said.

The debate focuses on Aberdeen's plan to draw up to 4.9 million gallons daily from the creek for the city's estimated 5,000 water customers.

Aberdeen already taps Deer Creek for Aberdeen Proving Ground, a military base that contracted with the city for water services.

Farmers and conservationists say Aberdeen is exaggerating its need for a second water source to support development.

Landowners along the creek, which runs from York, Pa., into Harford County and eventually the Susquehanna, for years have used the creek to water their farms and nurseries, and they say Aberdeen's plan would jeopardize their livelihood and harm aquatic life.

Philbrick dismissed those fears. He said numerous environmental studies prove the creek would not be harmed under Aberdeen's plan.

The Deer Creek Watershed Association and Harford County have both appealed the state environmental department's approval of Aberdeen's permit.

Should the MDE decision be overturned, any vote by the river basin commission would be overturned, a commission spokeswoman said.

Even with a commission vote next spring, Philbrick, in his second year on the commission, said he expected further appeals.

"Aberdeen and the [state environmental] department are prepared that this could take a while, maybe a year or two to work it through," he said.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.