Pollution fears threaten a way of life

Alaska: Reports of tainted animals have the native Chevak tribe reconsidering their traditional and healthy subsistence diet.

Medicine & Science

September 20, 2004|By Tom Horton | Tom Horton,SUN STAFF

CHEVAK, Alaska - Even maps of Alaska often don't identify Kokechik Bay, a small inlet of the Bering Sea in the vast delta between the Yukon and Kuskokwim Rivers. No one lives there except for half a dozen contractors manning a Cold War-era radar site, still trained on the former Soviet Union.

But the bay has always been life itself to a few thousand members of Alaska's native tribes in three nearby subsistence villages.

"Our elders always used to tell us, in times of hardship, Kokechik Bay is the place you go, the place you can rely on even in bad times," recalls Richard Tuluq, tribal administrator of Chevak.

In recent years, however, Tuluq says, people here and members of other Bering coast tribes in neighboring Hooper Bay and Scammon Bay have virtually ceased harvesting Arctic cod, blackfish, clams and other traditional foods from Kokechik.

While they still fish elsewhere, Alaskan natives are increasingly troubled by evidence of contamination in this corner of the million-square mile Bering Sea - source of about half of all seafood caught in the United States.

Amid reports of toxic leaks from the radar station at nearby Cape Romanzof, and of pollutants from distant lands carried here by winds and ocean currents, the natives worry that there is a link to rising adult cancer rates among their people and sharp increases in early childhood illnesses such as pneumonia and chronic infections. They complain of increased encounters with tumors and other mysterious abnormalities in fish, shellfish and bird eggs in the Kokechik Bay region.

"The food from there is not the same as when I was younger," said James Gump, 78, a Hooper Bay native who volunteers at the village school to teach children about traditional hunting and fishing techniques.

To subsistence peoples, this is worrisome in a way that the outside world of supermarket shoppers can scarcely imagine.

From whales, walruses and sea lions to berries and buttercups, the natives of this harsh coastal plain depend on what they get from the natural environment for survival.

"If you gave me enough money to buy everything at the store, I would probably spend it on more hunting gear," tribal hunter and fisherman Albert Simon says over a lunch of dried salmon soaked in seal oil and frozen herring roe. "Our cultural identity is based on subsistence ... and you know, it's fun."

Scientists and health experts don't agree on whether the contamination showing up in fish and wildlife here poses a threat to natives' health. But they do worry that fear is helping drive people from historically healthy subsistence diets to eating more modern processed foods.

That shift in consumption could be causing some of the ailments people are attributing to pollution, experts say - not to mention speeding the unraveling of traditional culture.

Increasingly vocal native groups are insisting on an accounting. "We want to find out what's in our environment, because that's our food ... that's what's in us," says Agatha Napoleon, a Hooper Bay resident who has led efforts to track contaminants from the Cape Romanzof radar station.

The same issues face native peoples from Alaska across Canada to Greenland, where studies have documented elevated levels of mercury, PCBs, pesticides and other toxic substances in the blood, hair and breast milk of people who eat a lot of wild fish and game.

Scientists and local leaders debate what is known as "the Arctic dilemma": how to answer natives' demands to know about the toxicants in their diet, without scaring them away from healthy traditional foods.

Evidence of health problems is compelling, even if the reasons are debatable.

"There has been a rise in cancers and other health problems - native kids in the Yukon-Kuskokwim area in their first year have 10 times the national rate of hospitalization for respiratory infections - so people are seeing things they've never seen before," says Dr. James Berner, a pediatrician in Alaska since 1974 and director of health for the Alaska Native Tribes Health Consortium in Anchorage.

The occurrence of cancer among Alaskan natives continues to rise, while rates are falling among U.S. whites. During the 1990s, studies showed natives here died of cancers at a 30 percent higher rate than whites. Lung and digestive system cancers were prominent.

Berner has found above-normal levels of toxic substances such cadmium, mercury and PCBs in blood from infants and their mothers in a number of Yukon delta tribal villages. He says studies from the eastern Canadian Arctic show that at high enough levels such chemicals do seem to cause significantly greater problems with infections.

A study of Inuit babies in northern Quebec, reported last year, detected subtle nervous-system and behavioral changes that researchers say appear to be linked with mercury and PCB contamination.

"But to date in our data here," Berner says, "the effects are pretty mild."

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.