Internet brings patent fight onto Md. college campuses

State investigates claims of tech firm

schools weigh licensing fees vs. legal cost

August 10, 2004|By Tricia Bishop | Tricia Bishop,SUN STAFF

The Maryland attorney general's office is investigating claims by a California technology company that several of the state's colleges and universities have infringed upon its patents by using the Internet to transmit video and audio.

"We're trying to review the situation and make some strategic decisions," Assistant Attorney General Thomas Faulk said yesterday. "We are first trying to determine whether or not we think there's any viability to the claim."

But even if the allegations are false, college officials say they might have no choice but to pay a fee for the technology, fearing the alternative is to go to court, which could cost millions of dollars in legal fees.

A division of Acacia Research Corp., based in Newport Beach, recently sent letters to dozens of higher education institutions across the country. Among them were Washington College in Chestertown, the University of Maryland, College Park and the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

The company claimed that schools using a form of streaming video or audio for online lectures or to transmit course material over the Internet were violating Acacia's patents on the technology if they weren't paying the company for that privilege.

The letters offered to set up licensing agreements with the schools for a minimum annual fee of $5,000. Otherwise, the company suggested that the schools would be sued.

Attorneys general in Georgia and Virginia are also investigating the claims. The company began contacting colleges last year.

`Very modest' fees

"These license fees that they're looking at are not going to put anybody out of business and they're not going to cause tuition increases. They're very, very modest licensing fees," said Robert Berman, Acacia's executive vice president for business development and general counsel.

"Colleges and universities are some of the biggest developers of technology," Berman said. "It's surprising that they would show less respect for our intellectual property than they require for their own."

Patent fights are common, especially in the area of technology. Yesterday, Google Inc. announced that it had settled a patent lawsuit with rival search engine Yahoo Inc. for more than $300 million in stock. The dispute was a threat to Google's much-publicized stock launch this month.

Last winter, the "MyDoom" virus that infected computers around the world was believed to be aimed at a Utah company that claims to hold rights to the open-source Linux system.

And Microsoft Corp. recently paid more than $62 million to settle a patent infringement lawsuit with another company over Internet conferencing technology.

Bullying tactics alleged

But the Acacia battle has alarmed the world of higher education, where administrators believe they are being targeted as a relatively easy and moneyed mark. Critics of Acacia say the company, which buys patents and makes its money enforcing them, is bullying people into paying for something its patents don't cover.

Acacia's letter to state colleges and university on July 27 came two weeks after a federal judge in Santa Ana, Calif., ruled that that some of the company's patents may be too vague to be enforced against several adult entertainment companies. That ruling sent the company's stock plummeting by half.

It closed down 4 cents to $2.95 on the Nasdaq stock market yesterday. The stock was above $6.50 a month ago.

"If you look at their strategy, they approached what they consider to be vulnerable industries, small porn sites for example, and try to get them to license the material rather than go to court," said Don Spicer, chief information officer for the University System of Maryland, which encompasses all but two of the state's public colleges and universities.

Spicer contacted the state attorney general's office when he received the letter from Acacia and is attempting to organize a united front among area colleges and universities.

No response, no lawsuit

The Johns Hopkins University received a letter from Acacia last year. Wes Blakeslee, an attorney for the university, wrote to the company but received no response - and no lawsuit. Still, Blakeslee recommends that schools take the situation seriously. He's working with the attorney general's office, as well as Baltimore-area schools and several organizations on the matter.

Acacia has filed similar suits of patent infringement against 47 adult entertainment companies and settled with 30 of them. Last month, it filed complaints against nine cable and satellite companies. Acacia has signed more than 160 licensing agreements with various companies, including the Walt Disney Corp.

Potential licensees include "anybody that provides streaming media - meaning audio, video and digital content - that can be looked at over the Internet," Berman said. "The first industry we started with was the adult entertainment industry, but we're also talking to sports, news and information sites, and, of course, colleges."

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.