Veteran female rockers return to scene

Singers resume careers after raising their children

August 03, 2004|By Julia Keller | Julia Keller,CHICAGO TRIBUNE

"`No one's young forever.'

Well, I just laughed

I turned to leave around the corner

And the years went past."- "You Can't Go Back," Patti Scialfa

It works like this: When you're young, you dream big dreams. Wild dreams. Outrageous dreams.

Then you grow up, get married, make a family. Along the way, you wad up the dream like a tie-dyed T-shirt - the kind of bold, crazy thing you'd never wear outside the house anymore - and you stash it in the attic.

But Patti Scialfa, Patti Smith and Annie Lennox didn't get the memo. No one told them that people in their late 40s, 50s and 60s - especially women with children - are supposed to settle down, keep that attic door closed.

Instead, in an extraordinary creative confluence that defies conventional ideas about age and gender and the shelf life of passionate imaginations, these female musicians are resuming careers that took a breather for child-rearing and home-making.

It's as if each woman were determined to recut the path to her creative center, a path sometimes obscured by the twisting foliage of everyday existence. Each woman is trying to answer T.S. Eliot's quietly urgent question: "Where is the Life we have lost in living?"

Scialfa, 50, has three kids, ages 13, 12 and 10. She recently released the CD 23rd Street Lullaby - which reached No. 2 on's sales rankings and has garnered mostly glowing reviews - 11 years after her first album Rumble Doll. In the past decade, her solo career had played second banana to family obligations - including husband Bruce Springsteen's tours and albums, on which she sings backup.

Smith, 57, a fiery, long-limbed legend in the 1970s for her slashing music and vividly original poetry, slipped from the scene in the late 1980s after marrying and bearing two children. Her latest CD, Trampin', which sold some 9,000 copies in its first week and has been almost unanimously hailed by critics, is livid with rejuvenated energy and eclecticism.

Annie Lennox, 49, the arrestingly androgynous half of the 1980s pop duo the Eurythmics, ratcheted down her public persona in the 1990s to raise two children. This summer, she's touring with Sting, performing songs from the eerily melodic 2003 CD Bare, which sold more than 150,000 copies in its first week.

This renaissance of creativity from mature women with children also includes Loretta Lynn, 69-year-old mother of six. The country icon released Van Lear Rose a few months ago, her first album in four years - and the first in her career in which she wrote all the songs.

The re-emergence of these artists defies the common notion that women must choose between their children and their muses, that creative achievement is incompatible with domestic duty. And it shreds as well the tired idea that children are a kind of substitute for artistic creations - that women who are mothers shouldn't continue to ache to express themselves.

Musicians such as Scialfa, Smith, Lennox and Lynn are following a new kind of career trajectory: Early success, followed by a voluntary hiatus in favor of home and family, then a return to the fierce demands of art.

Like all cultural changes, this one is shaped by many factors. Audiences themselves are aging, and they want to see their experiences reflected in artists who have lived full and varied lives. A century's worth of progress for women has gradually scratched away at the thick barrier that used to divide the world between "career gals" and wives and mothers.

Call it the anti-Britney Spears effect: These women have lived awhile and look it. And they have something to say.

Until recently, though, they weren't free to say it. The history of creative women has not included much sympathy or understanding for women who wanted to do both: make art and babies. As Tillie Olsen argued in her classic 1978 book Silences, women traditionally were forced to choose - between their ambitions and their responsibilities; between top-40 hits and happy children; between being poets and novelists and being wives and mothers. That took a toll on female artistic output, Olsen insisted, and resulted in unnatural silences.

Some were stifled after a single great work - think of Emily Bronte - while others never got going in the first place. The thing about wasted potential, of course, is that the world doesn't know what it lost.

To create and maintain their art, women must believe that what they say is worthwhile. They have to step up, as Lynn does in "Story of My Life," the last song on Van Lear Rose, and confidently declare, "Well, here's the story of my life/Listen and I'll tell it twice."

Too often, women's voices - especially the voices of women whose lives were associated with domestic tasks - went unheard, as Olsen noted. Until the 20th century, when women's lives were unshackled and their imaginations sought creative expression, the world missed many treasures because no one bothered to look.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.