West's spies listened in on U.N.'s Annan

Ex-Blair Cabinet member reveals eavesdropping before start of Iraq war

February 27, 2004|By Todd Richissin and Scott Shane | Todd Richissin and Scott Shane,SUN STAFF

LONDON - British intelligence agents were involved in intercepting conversations of U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan in the weeks before the Iraq war, according to a former Cabinet member in Prime Minister Tony Blair's administration who said she read the transcripts.

The highly unusual revelation by Clare Short, former international development secretary, made public what has long been an unspoken assumption among foreign diplomats in the United States: Their phone calls and office conversations are routinely intercepted by the National Security Agency and its British equivalent, the Government Communications Headquarters, which work closely together.

"I have seen transcripts of Kofi Annan's conversations," Short told a British Broadcasting Corp. interviewer. "Indeed, I have had conversations with Kofi in the run-up to war thinking, `Oh dear, there will be a transcript of this and people will see what he and I are saying.'"

Short's statement - the second leak about U.S. and British eavesdropping at the United Nations since last year - put Blair in the awkward position of denouncing her indiscretion without admitting the truth of her claim.

Blair called her statement "totally irresponsible." But he refused to confirm or deny the allegations, saying that no prime minister or president "anywhere in the world" would discuss spy operations, even to refute false charges.

At U.N. headquarters in New York, a spokesman for Annan said that if the charges were true, Annan was "disappointed" and wanted the eavesdropping stopped.

"Such activities would undermine the integrity and confidential nature of diplomatic exchanges," spokesman Fred Eckhard said. "Those who speak to the secretary-general are entitled to assume that their exchanges are confidential."

He said Annan's office "routinely takes technical measures" to prevent eavesdropping. "Those efforts will now be intensified," Eckhard said.

That, said a former NSA official, is exactly why the spy agencies shudder when evidence of their eavesdropping is trumpeted in public.

"Every time something is leaked, it alerts the targets to tighten up their communications security," said Mike Levin, who worked for the NSA at Fort Meade from 1947 to 1993, retiring as chief of information policy. "That makes NSA's job a lot more difficult."

Levin, like other intelligence veterans, said the United States routinely eavesdrops on diplomats and U.N. officials in order to understand their private thinking and plans.

Under a half-century-old arrangement among the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, the countries' eavesdropping agencies coordinate their work and share the results.

"What they're doing is what every nation in the world has always done: gathering as much information as possible," Levin said. "Anyone who suggests this is shocking is being foolish."

Short made her claims on Radio 4, part of the BBC, while being interviewed about a decision Wednesday by prosecutors here to abandon a criminal case against Katharine Gun under Britain's Official Secrets Act.

Gun, a 29-year-old Chinese linguist for GCHQ, had acknowledged leaking a top-secret NSA memo that detailed plans to boost eavesdropping on the U.N. delegations of six countries last year as the United States sought a U.N. Security Council vote in favor of using force against Iraq.

"The U.K. in this time was also spying on Kofi Annan's office and getting reports from him about what was going on," Short said in the interview. "These things are done, and in the case of Kofi's office, it was being done for some time."

Asked whether British agents were involved, she replied, "Yes, absolutely."

Intelligence experts said yesterday that it was more likely that the NSA intercepted Annan's conversations, though the GCHQ might have assisted and certainly received the resulting transcripts.

Short is viewed somewhat as a loose cannon whose estrangement from Blair did not end with her resignation. Although a member of his Labor Party, she is a fixture on television news shows in Britain and rarely misses an opportunity to criticize him. She has repeatedly called on him to resign for what she said was misleading the country to ally itself against Iraq with the United States.

Before the war, she had threatened to resign her Cabinet post if Blair took the country to war. She changed her mind, cast a vote in the House of Commons in support of the invasion - then resigned in May, saying she was protesting the lack of U.N. involvement in rebuilding.

Blair was clearly perturbed during his news conference and acknowledged that "conspiracy theorists" would interpret his comments as a government cover-up of illegal spying.

The prime minister has faced a drubbing in the British media for months for his conduct before the war - chief among the criticisms being that he exaggerated the threat posed by Saddam Hussein - and his popularity has fallen as a result.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.