1873: Survivor
1874: Culpepper
1875: Tom Ochiltree
1876: Shirley
1877: Cloverbrook
1878: Duke of Magenta
1879: Harold
1873: Survivor
1874: Culpepper
1875: Tom Ochiltree
1876: Shirley
1877: Cloverbrook
1878: Duke of Magenta
1879: Harold
1880: Grenada
1881: Saunterer
1882: Vanguard
1883: Jacobus
1884: Knight of Ellerslie
1885: Tecumseh
1886: The Bard
1887: Dunboyne
1888: Refund
1889: Buddhist
1890: Montague
1891-93: No races
1894: Assignee
1895: Belmar
1896: Margrave
1897: Paul Kauvar
1898: Sly Fox
1899: Half Time
1900: Hindus
1901: The Parader
1902: Old England
1903: Flocarline
1904: Bryn Mawr
1905: Cairngorm
1906: Whimsical
1907: Don Enrique
1908: Royal Tourist
1909: Effendi
1910: Layminster
1911: Watervale
1912: Colonel Holloway
1913: Buskin
1914: Holiday
1915: Rhine Maiden
1916: Damrosch
1917: Kalitan
1918: War Cloud and Jack Hare, Jr.
1919: Sir Barton
1920: Man o' War
1921: Broomspun
1922: Pillory
1923: Vigil
1924: Nellie Morse
1925: Coventry
1926: Display
1927: Bostonian
1928: Victorian
1929: Dr. Freeland
1930: Gallant Fox
1931: Mate
1932: Burgoo King
1933: Head Play
1934: High Quest
1935: Omaha
1936: Bold Venture
1937: War Admiral
1938: Dauber
1939: Challedon
1940: Bimelech
1941: Whirlaway
1942: Alsab
1943: Count Fleet
1944: Pensive
1945: Polynesian
1946: Assault
1947: Faultless
1948: Citation
1949: Capot
1950: Hill Prince
1951: Bold
1952: Blue Man
1953: Native Dancer
1954: Hasty Road
1955: Nashua
1956: Fabius
1957: Bold Ruler
1958: Tim Tam
1959: Royal Orbit
1960: Bally Ache
1961: Carry Back
1962: Greek Money
1963: Candy Spots
1964: Northern Dancer
1965: Tom Rolfe
1966: Kauai King
1967: Damascus
1968: Forward Pass
1969: Majestic Prince
1970: Personality
1971: Canonero II
1972: Bee Bee Bee
1973: Secretariat
1974: Little Current
1975: Master Derby
1976: Elocutionist
1977: Seattle Slew
1978: Affirmed
1979: Spectacular Bid
1980: Codex
1981: Pleasant Colony
1982: Aloma's Ruler
1983: Deputed Testamony
1984: Gate Dancer
1985: Tank's Prospect
1986: Snow Chief
1987: Alysheba
1988: Risen Star
1989: Sunday Silence
1990: Summer Squall
1991: Hansel
1992: Pine Bluff
1993: Prairie Bayou
1994: Tabasco Cat
1995: Timber Country
1996: Louis Quatorze
1997: Silver Charm
1998: Real Quiet
1999: Charismatic
2000: Red Bullet
2001: Point Given
2002: War Emblem