Church bashing delights the left

May 08, 2002|By Cal Thomas

ARLINGTON, Va. -- Politically liberal and religiously secular people are having too good a time beating up on the Roman Catholic Church.

Lefties, who would never tolerate stereotyping their favorite groups (blacks, women and gays come to mind as examples), think nothing of universally condemning all things Catholic for the despicable sexual actions of what appears to be a relatively small number of priests and the cover-up by some higher-ups in the church.

Media commentators are among the worst offenders. Not since the "high-tech lynching" of Clarence Thomas and the scandals involving certain TV evangelists have they enjoyed themselves this much.

They get the added benefit of covering themselves in faux righteousness, pretending to care about the health and welfare of a church in which most have little or no part, while simultaneously and hypocritically giving it a public flogging.

One such commentator is Bill Keller of The New York Times. In his May 4 column, Mr. Keller admits, "I am what a friend calls a `collapsed Catholic' -- well beyond lapsed -- and therefore claim no voice in whom the church ordains or how it prays or what it chooses to call a sin."

Such a confession doesn't stop Mr. Keller, however, from giving what might be called "collapsed advice."

According to Mr. Keller, who echoes other critics, the Catholic Church's problem is that it is not modern and refuses to take marching orders from the likes of people such as himself.

The "gospel" according to Mr. Keller and his fellow collapsees is that the Catholic Church -- and by implication all religion -- must conduct the ultimate makeover and adapt to this present age.

Ozzy Osbourne might fit Mr. Keller's ideal of a popular "pope," since the chief contribution of Mr. Osbourne and his family appears to be providing distractions and entertainment for the damned.

Modernization, to Mr. Keller, seems to mean no prohibition against anything the spiritually collapsed want to do, including abortion and sexual activity of all kinds between consenting adults.

As Charles Stanley, senior pastor of First Baptist Church in Atlanta, once observed in a sermon: "We have come a long way from little Samuel, who said, `Speak, Lord, for thy servant heareth,' to our present moment when we say, `Listen, Lord, for thy servant speaketh.'"

The arrest last week of the Rev. Paul Shanley on charges of raping a young boy while he was a Boston priest is one example of the media piling-on.

William Donohue, president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights, believes the media have not given a full picture of the Shanley case.

The priest's allegedly abusive behavior was, in fact, the result of his defying church teachings on sexual matters, Mr. Donohue notes.

In a Catholic League news release Friday, Mr. Donohue writes that in 1970, Mr. Shanley "got the green light from Cardinal Humberto Medeiros," then the archbishop of Boston, who appointed Mr. Shanley as his "representative for sexual minorities."

Not only was this a "bizarre ministry," notes Mr. Donohue, but Mr. Shanley was openly gay, which, in itself, defied church teachings on sexuality.

In 1979, Cardinal Medeiros ended Mr. Shanley's "special ministry."

Mr. Shanley then denounced Cardinal Medeiros because the cardinal had admonished gays to abstain from sex, which Mr. Shanley branded as "virtually useless advice."

Critics inside and outside the Catholic Church are right to call for an investigation of the cover-up of sexual crimes by priests and for new rules governing behavior and accountability.

But the media should be ashamed that they are using the horror of adult-child sexual abuse, and even sex between consenting adults, as a flimsy excuse to wallow in unrestrained bigotry.

If anyone needs to "modernize," it's the bigots.

Cal Thomas' syndicated column appears in The Sun Wednesdays.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.