A smart-growth pioneer arises

Renovating the Stewart's / Caldor York Road property is an exercise in innovation.

Architecture: Review

May 27, 2001|By Edward Gunts | Edward Gunts,Sun Architecture Critic

Stewart's department store was an architectural pioneer when it opened on York Road in 1955. It was part of an early wave of downtown-based retailers venturing into the counties. It anchored a shopping center that contained such one-time Baltimore mainstays as Hamburger's, Peck and Peck and Silber's Bake Shop. Its exterior and site plan were the work of the noted industrial designer Raymond Loewy.

Now the Stewart's property has a chance to be a pioneer all over again, this time as an example of environmentally sensitive development and "Smart Growth" principles. Its conversion to offices for Baltimore County and the state of Maryland, now under way, will improve the appearance of a key stretch of York Road and help revitalize the surrounding area.

In an age when shifting shopping patterns are rendering some retail operations obsolete, it's a timely reminder that there's more than one way to skin a department store.

The conversion was launched earlier this year to house employees from Towson's Investment Building, the 13-story structure where workers have complained of health problems they believe are caused by poor indoor air quality and lax maintenance.

After considering four possible locations, state and county officials selected the former Stewart's property at 6401 York Road as the place to move approximately 1,000 office workers. After renovations are completed by a private group, the county will acquire the building for $19 million.

The decision showed foresight because the Stewart's property has a 45-year history as a location for shopping, not offices.

A modern Main Street

As the first of five suburban outlets for Stewart & Co., whose downtown flagship stood at Howard and Lexington streets, it was quite an attraction in its day. It boasted the largest display of home furnishings on one floor in the Baltimore area, "escalators to whisk you from one level to another," and intricate seed mosaics by artist Carl Mann. "Here is the convenience of Main Street in a suburban setting," cooed the opening day ad.

After Stewart's closed in 1983 -- the last store in the chain to do so -- the building was converted to a branch of Caldor, which billed itself as the Bloomingdale's of discounting. But Caldor shut down in 1999, and the site has been dormant ever since.

The owners might have found another retailer to take Caldor's place. But the shopping industry is such that big-box retailers like to be near each other, and the 10-acre Anneslie Shopping Center lacks room for more than one.

Converting the store to offices makes sense because it helps fill a vacant building in a prominent location and brings in office workers who will patronize shops up and down York Road. The property has ample free parking and easy access from several directions. The structure is sturdy and floor-to-ceiling heights are more generous than they are for most office buildings.

Baltimore County Executive C. A. Dutch Ruppersberger said he originally thought of moving office workers from the Investment Building to the former Caldor in Timonium, because it's near the state's light rail line. But when it turned out there wasn't sufficient parking near the Timonium building, he said, officials explored other county locations and decided the former Caldor in Anneslie was the best.

The building is two miles south of Towson, well-served by public transportation, and has decked parking in the rear, Ruppersberger noted. Because it's just north of the city-county line, he said, the influx of employees will help merchants and businesses in both jurisdictions. "It's going to make a big difference."

The renovation will also remove an eyesore from York Road. Although the Stewart's building was innovative for its time -- designed to be a full-service department store, not a branch -- it wasn't much to look at. Despite the connection to Loewy (who also designed Stewart's Reisterstown Road store), it was essentially a windowless box with white brick, stone and slate accents, and colored awnings. It didn't have the gentle curves of the Hutzler's building in Towson or the glass corner of the Hochschild-Kohn at York and Belvedere. The conversion to Caldor, with metal panels on the side and a blocky corner entry, made it look worse. Boarded up, it was even uglier.

The developer is 6401 York Road Associates LLC, a local group headed by Larry Boltansky. The architect is Fishman Curry and Associates of Owings Mills, and Proutt Construction is the construction manager.

Boltansky said he read about the Investment Building's troubles in the newspaper, drove up and down York Road looking for an alternative site, got the Caldor building under contract, and let state officials know it was available for conversion in the event they decide to relocate employees. He said he didn't think it would attract another major retailer because the interiors weren't designed for today's businesses.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.