Drug plan is good idea -- with strict oversight

July 02, 1999

An excerpt from a Los Angeles Times editorial that ran Wednesday:

When the legislation that created Medicare was enacted in 1965, doctors depended more on surgery than drugs to treat serious ailments such as heart disease and cancer. Basic medical care for disabled and elderly Americans should include hospital care, yes, and doctor visits, yes. But prescription drugs were not on the legislative radar.

As President Clinton repeatedly has pointed out, medical care has advanced in ways that Medicare has not. Today, prescription drugs extend life spans by decades. That's why Mr. Clinton was right Tuesday to outline a plan for adding a modest drug coverage option to Medicare. The biggest benefit might be not the direct payments but Medicare's price-bargaining power with drug makers, who shudder at the prospect of volume discounts that would cut into their record profits.

The pharmaceutical industry is already planning a $30 million, "Harry-and-Louise"-style advertising campaign to deride the president's plan as big-government price controls. Actually the plan would do the opposite, bringing a breeze of competitive pressure to the nation's drug market.

The Clinton plan would give Medicare recipients the option of paying a monthly $24 premium to get a modest $1,000-a-year prescription drug benefit; by 2008, a beneficiary would pay a monthly premium of $44 to be covered for up to $2,500 worth of drugs. With Medicare's ability to bargain for better prices, that $2,500 could go much further than it does now. Mr. Clinton proposes dedicating $45.5 billion of the budget surplus to pay for the drug coverage through 2008; some of that and other Medicare spending would be offset by efficiency savings from Medicare operations, says the White House. That is a song that's been sung before, and too often the savings do not materialize. Tough oversight would be crucial.

Mr. Clinton's proposal is the right thing, but caution should be the watchword to keep spending under control.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.