Army crunches gender gap

Fitness: A new three-part Army fitness test holds men and women to similar standards.

February 17, 1999|By Tom Bowman | Tom Bowman,SUN NATIONAL STAFF

FORT MEADE -- Quietly and without fanfare, men and women in the Army achieved a measure of equality last week on a muddy practice field.

Sgt. Corinne Castanza and Spc. Omari Walker had to complete at least 50 sit-ups to pass the Army's new physical fitness test.

Five years in the making, the new test narrows a gender gap that caused grumbling from male soldiers, who complained that women were getting off easy on the semiannual test that also requires push-ups and and a 2-mile run.

And there's a lot at stake in the three events of the test: The fitness score is among the factors considered for promotions and entry into advanced Army courses.

The new test, which went into effect Feb. 1, requires a faster 2-mile run for most women, although they still don't have to match the time of male soldiers. Nor do they have to complete as many push-ups.

"I think it's pretty equitable as far as sit-ups for men and women," said Castanza, a petite 23-year-old from upstate New York, who has heard male griping about the old test. "Even from my husband. thought the standards were higher for men than women," she said of Cpl. Vincent Castanza, who will take his test soon.

The new test "seems fair," agreed Walker, 22, a long and lean soldier from Kansas City, Mo. "The ab muscles aren't that different between men and women."

In 1992, top Army officers asked for a study to determine whether the fitness test, devised eight years earlier, was equitable for men and women, and among the various age groups. The test gauges overall fitness, rather than the physical qualifications for a particular job, such as paratrooper.

The Army tested 2,588 men and women at a dozen posts around the world and concluded that changes were needed. Many of the minimum requirements were increased to reflect the heightened fitness of the average soldier, while some of the maximums, deemed unattainable, were decreased.

"The majority of people in all age groups have to do more. They have to run faster, do more push-ups and do more sit-ups," said Col. Stephen D. Cellucci, commandant of the Army Physical Fitness School at Fort Benning, Ga.

The old test was flawed, full of guesswork and lacking physiological research on appropriate maximum scores, Cellucci said.

Half of the women were receiving the maximum score in the run. Women in the 27-31 age group had to run two miles in 17 minutes to score the maximum 100 points. Now, they have to complete the run in 15: 48 to get the top score.

The new fitness test better reflects the differences in ability and physiology between men and women, said Cellucci. Since men have greater upper body strength, stronger legs and larger hearts, they are able to complete more push-ups and run faster. But sit-ups are a different matter, the research showed.

"In sit-ups, women can probably do 1 to 2 percent more than men," said Cellucci. "What we decided, since it's so negligible, `Let's come up with one standard.' "

Overall, the test was designed to offer men and women "the same points for the same effort."

Lt. Gen. William J. Bolt, a senior commander at the Army's Training and Doctrine Command, declared the new standards "tough, challenging, realistic and achievable."

On a dank overcast afternoon last week, Castanza, Walker and 16 other soldiers from Bravo Company of the 741st Battalion, 704th Military Intelligence Brigade assembled at Mullins Field here, dressed in identical pale-gray sweat shirts, for their test.

While a camouflage-clad sergeant squatted with a stop watch, Castanza plopped down on the damp grass and began her two-minutes of sit-ups, her face shading red as she passed the 50 mark.

Since she's in the 22 to 26 age group, Castanza must do five more sit-ups than in the previous test, when 45 would earn the passing grade of 60. As a male, Walker must do three more sit-ups to reach the necessary 50 in the same age group.

By the time the stopwatch hit the two-minute mark, Castanza had surged through the passing grade to complete 68 sit-ups; Walker had made it to 63.

"I have a sit-up bar at home and do them while I watch TV," said Castanza, although: "I lean more toward crunches."

Still, both soldiers completed fewer sit-ups than their last test.

On the other hand, Castanza's extra workouts in preparation for the new test paid off as she shattered the expectations for both men and women in the push-up event.

The sergeant did 45 push-ups, far more than the 17 she needed to pass the test and four more than a man needed to pass. Walker made it to 44.

For Walker and other younger soldiers, the times for the 2-mile run have not changed. But the run has caused heartburn in the over-30 set -- for men and women.

To achieve a passing score in the run, women ages 32 to 41 must run nearly a minute faster than in the previous test. And the men have seen their time cut.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.