Any 'greatest generation is rank ancestor worship

The Argument

Calling the World War II generation America's finest is bad history, bad judgment and bad balance.

January 31, 1999|By Theo Lippman Jr. | Theo Lippman Jr.,Special to the Sun

The big best seller of the winter is a reminder that from time to time Americans succumb to a frenzy of ancestor worship. This is a silly and dangerous indulgence, as the late, great Johns Hopkins historian J. Franklin Jameson explained on the eve of the 150th anniversary of the Revolutionary War. In an essay, he condemned "the notion that, because in the period of the Revolution there were many heroic characters and deeds, the whole American population of that time was heroic."

He went on to say: "It is pleasant to think well of a whole generation of those who have preceded us, and especially pleasant to glorify them if they were our ancestors. It may seem harmless, but when it is done in terms of comparison with later generations it is not altogether wholesome."

The best seller is "The Greatest Generation" by Tom Brokaw (Random House, 412 pages, $24.95). The anchorman-author makes the simple-minded, wrong-headed and not altogether wholesome assertion that the Americans who waged and won World War II were "the greatest generation any society has ever produced."

The book is a collection of short biographies of some 50 members of the revered generation, what they did before, during and after the war. The chapters read like Ralph Edwards' introductions of his subjects on one of the greatest generation's favorite post-war TV shows, "This Is Your Life," as cleared by the Office of War Information.

But style is the least of the problems with this book. More important is lack of expertise. Brokaw says he read three historians of the war, but his book shows no evidence of research into earlier or later generations' accomplishments in America or any other society. Nor that he knows much about what went on in America in the 1940s.

More important still is that he inflates a select group of people into emblems of an entire generation, the very thing Jameson objected to. Brokaw's choices are hardly typical of their generation. Four-fifths of the men and women he features were in the military, and many saw real combat.

Now, only roughly two-thirds of American men ages 17-35 served in any branch of the services, 1940-1945. Three-fourths of those never went overseas. Of those who did, less than half saw even low intensity combat.

So about one in 12 at most of the young men of that day really sacrificed to the point that they deserve reverence -- and at least two-thirds of those were drafted. So many young men dodged military service by going to college, getting war factory or agricultural jobs, claiming bad health or pacifism or marrying and fathering that beginning in 1942 even the Navy couldn't meet its manpower needs with enlistments.

There were plenty of good jobs to go around. Average family income more than doubled between 1938 and 1942 in many cities. Wealth and spending exploded. Many manufacturers, who had suffered in the Great Depression, were more interested in producing consumer goods than war materiel.

Hoarding was widespread. So was black market activity. The good times rolled. The war was the best thing that ever happened to millions and millions of Americans of the greatest generation.

These and similar facts about those times are freely available to serious researchers. Even non-serious researchers can learn plenty about the war years and the vast literature on them in either of two small books with local connections. One is "Wartime America: The World War II Home Front" by John W. Jeffries (Ivan R. Dee, 213 pages, $24.95). Professor Jeffries teaches history at UMBC. The other is "The Best War Ever: America and World War II" by Michael C.C. Adams (Johns Hopkins University Press, 189 pages, $14.95 paper).

Both are well-written, un-stuffy. The former has a good "A Note on Sources" but no footnotes. The latter has a good "Bibliographic Essay" and is footnoted.

It's not just Tom Brokaw who is demonstrating that Americans want to worship their ancestors these days. One week this winter his book was No. 1 on the New York Times nonfiction best seller list. No. 2 was "The Century" by Peter Jennings and Todd Brewster (Doubleday, 606 pages, $60). No. 6 was "The American Century" by Harold Evans with Gail Buckland and Kevin Baker (Knopf, 710 pages, $50).

The latter two are celebrity journalists' coffee table books, but wonderfully illustrated, and also well researched and written. The Evans book can stand up to most narrative histories of the eras. Both books are respectful but not worshipful of the World War II fighting generation. And Evans is balanced in assessing America's "greatness" in the war.

Then there is Stephen Ambrose (a friend and source of Brokaw's). The former Hopkins history professor's "The Victors" (Simon & Schuster, 396 pages, $28) was No. 15 on that same best seller list. It is a synthesis of several of his earlier books about World War II, including the 1997 "Citizen Soldiers," the re-issued edition of which was No. 10 on the Times paperback best seller list the same week.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.