President wants to use surplus to preserve Social Security system

Proposal puts $700 billion into stock market, sets up new retirement accounts

State Of Union

January 20, 1999|By Jonathan Weisman | Jonathan Weisman,SUN NATIONAL STAFF

WASHINGTON -- President Clinton yesterday proposed to use nearly all of the federal government's burgeoning budget surplus to shore up Social Security and create new individual retirement savings accounts for most American workers.

Following up on last year's pledge to "save Social Security first," Clinton again made the popular retirement security program the centerpiece of his State of the Union address, with a dramatic proposal that is sure to irk Republicans and Democrats alike.

The plan, which calls for investing up to $700 billion in federal budget surpluses in the stock market, would be the most far-reaching change in Social Security financing since the system was created 64 years ago.

"You really have a fundamental choice," said Gene Sperling, chairman of the president's National Economic Council. "We have over $4 trillion in budget surpluses over the next 15 years. We could consume that now and let our children figure out what to do with Social Security and Medicare, or we can use this moment, when the sun is shining, to lift the burden off future generations."

Clinton's proposal would tie up those budget surpluses for more than a decade, potentially foreclosing GOP plans for an across-the-board election-year tax cut next year. Under the plan, about 62 percent of the surplus -- or $2.7 trillion -- would go directly to bolster Social Security's cash reserves, which are expected to dwindle rapidly once the baby boomer generation begins to retire around 2010.

Another 11 percent, or $500 billion, would go to new, government-subsidized retirement savings accounts. Some 15 percent of the surplus would be dedicated to strengthening Medicare, the federal medical program for disabled and senior citizens that faces the most immediate cash crunch.

The rest -- about 11 percent -- would be spent on military and domestic programs.

Sperling estimated yesterday that the proposal would keep Social Security solvent until 2055, 23 years past the date that the program is now expected to go broke. Medicare would be kept afloat through 2020.

Other structural changes may be needed, such as raising the retirement age, taxing more of the income of the rich, or subjecting more taxpayers, including some government workers, to the Social Security payroll tax. But White House aides say those tough decisions will have to be negotiated with Congress.

Those blanks in the proposal are sure to incur the rhetorical wrath of the GOP. Senate Republican Leader Trent Lott yesterday repeated his demand for a detailed Social Security reform bill in legislative language.

"That is presidential leadership. That's the leadership that is required in order to get an important job like this done," Lott said. "It's not enough to say we need to do it. He's got to give us the specifics."

Clinton's proposal is significant in part because it could bridge a deep partisan divide on the politically treacherous issue of Social Security. As part of any reform plan, Republicans have demanded some savings account component, in which individuals can control some tax money and invest it as they choose. Democrats have said such accounts would subject retirement security to the caprices of the stock market, while enabling knowledgeable, high-income Americans to increase the already growing gap between rich and poor.

Clinton's plan would give Republicans something of what they wanted, but funding for the accounts would not come from the existing Social Security system, whose guaranteed benefits would remain intact.

Still, even some Democrats believe the White House plan is too timid. Rep. Benjamin L. Cardin, a Baltimore Democrat who is completing his own Social Security proposal, noted that although 62 percent of the budget surplus would be roped off for Social Security under the proposal, no more than a quarter of that would be available to invest in stocks.

The rest of the money would be used to draw down the federal debt by retiring outstanding Treasury bonds without issuing more, as the government has done for years. By reducing the debt now, administration officials say, the nation will make more money available for Social Security when baby boomers begin to retire.

"I personally would be more aggressive," Cardin said.

Almost all the money going into the stock market would be controlled by fund managers under contract with the federal government, a proposal that key Republicans vehemently oppose. The $700 billion in federal money that would flow into the markets over the next 15 years would represent just 4 percent of the total money currently in the nation's stock markets, Sperling said, about the same amount controlled by mutual fund giant Fidelity Investments. And the funds would be channeled mainly into mutual funds tied to the performance of the broad stock market and not to the stocks of individual companies.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.