India's risky entry into arms race Bombs: Defying world opinion, India conducted underground nuclear tests this week and inspired national pride. But will the consequences be worth it?

Sun Journal

May 16, 1998|By Miriam Jordan | Miriam Jordan,SPECIAL TO THE SUN

NEW DELHI -- When India first flexed its atomic muscle in 1974, it chose a national holiday that celebrates Buddha's achievement of enlightenment. To inform Prime Minister Indira Gandhi that the test explosion had succeeded, her advisers flashed a message: "The Buddha is smiling."

Twenty-four years later on the same holiday, Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee proudly announced that India had detonated three underground nuclear tests at the same desert site near the Pakistan border. Two days later, India conducted two more underground nuclear tests.

The country erupted with defiant joy. But the United States swiftly imposed trade sanctions on a large democracy with which Washington wants stronger ties. And Pakistan suggested that it would test its own nuclear device.

The blasts send South Asia hurtling toward a risky arms race that such a poor and overpopulated region can hardly afford. India, with a stable democracy, emerging middle class and growing economy, seems to have favorable prospects. Why would it risk its recent gains?

The fact that India, one of the original champions of nuclear disarmament, went ahead with the tests says a lot about how both India and the world have changed since the Buddha smiled at Indira Gandhi in 1974.

"We are a global player now," declares Pramod Mahajan, an aide to the prime minister.

For the 2-month-old government led by the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party, the decision to go nuclear is the ultimate show of strength: It affirms India's scientific achievements, defies world opinion and solidifies the BJP's domestic power as a party that ended 24 years of nuclear ambiguity and will not equivocate in defending what it sees as India's interests. India had been torn over how to project its nuclear prowess. It developed atomic weapons technology secretly and never signed international treaties, which it said favored the five nuclear powers. Two years ago a previous Indian government buckled to a U.S. threat of sanctions and scrapped a planned nuclear test.

For the BJP, which has long advocated declaring India a nuclear-weapons power, domestic opinion is paramount. "People felt that the policy of restraint improved neither India's image nor its security," says Dhirubhai Sheth, a political sociologist at the Center for the Study of Developing Societies in New Delhi.

While India held back from testing and deploying nuclear weapons, he notes, "national pride was hurt" when violators of international law, particularly China, got away with hardly a slap on the wrist from the United States.

Vajpayee's order to conduct five underground blasts is wildly popular here. In New Delhi, well-wishers flocked to his residence to greet him with marigold garlands and patriotic banners. Villagers in the northwestern state of Rajasthan celebrated with song and dance as word spread that the explosions they had heard in the distance emanated from bombs.

"We may be poor, but we have shown we are great. We did this on our own," says K. L. Munjala, shopkeeper in New Delhi. Krishnan Khosla, a college student, adds: "For 24 years we waited. It's high time that we showed we are at a par with other countries, not backward."

Newspaper editorials echoed the theme. The Pioneer hailed "an explosion of self-esteem." A front-page editorial in the Indian Express praised a "jump-start to India's dormant, free spirit."

India justifies the tests on security grounds. Its most immediate tension is with Pakistan, with which it has fought three wars since 1947. But Vajpayee cited China, the emerging economic and military superpower on India's disputed northern border.

How real is the China threat? Chinese experts say that India ranks low on the list of Beijing's strategic interests, well below the problem with Taiwan. Even China's initial reaction to the Indian bomb test was muted. Only after the second set of tests did China accuse India of trying to "dominate" South Asia.

The two Asian giants fought a brief border war in the Himalayas in 1962, decisively won by China. India chafes at Beijing's military aid to Pakistan, and China resents India's sympathy for Tibet's spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama. But there is no immediate threat of a military conflict.

Still, defense analysts here insist that China poses a long-term security threat and that the nuclear tests have helped to level the diplomatic and military playing field. "China will have to learn to live with India being an equal," says Brahma Chellaney, professor of security studies at the Center for Policy Research, a think tank in New Delhi.

Perhaps more important to Vajpayee's Hindu nationalist party is the domestic political payoff. The more severe the international reaction to India's bomb, the easier it will be for the BJP to capitalize on resentment of the United States and other critics.

"Treating India as a rogue state, like Iraq or North Korea, is real fodder for militant nationalism," says Sheth, the political sociologist.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.