The battle for Harvard Square Endangered: Preservationists are fighting a holding action as quirky eateries and unique buildings give way to Starbucks and chain stores in this outpost of urban eclecticism.

Sun Journal

December 13, 1996|By Joe Mathews | Joe Mathews,SUN STAFF

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- If this fiercely independent city has a spiritual center, it is neither a church nor a synagogue nor a mosque. It is Harvard Square. As chain outlets and malls spread across the rest of the country, the small, independent merchants here shrugged, disdaining the accouterments of late 20th century capitalism.

The Square is the half-dozen blocks near the confluence of Massachusetts Avenue and JFK Street. By the standards of the contemporary urban United States, it is a rare social leveler. Wealthy lawyers have coexisted comfortably with the homeless, crowded bars with packed churches, ethnic restaurants with the WASPiest Harvard clubs.

But the last few years have brought a change. Natives compare it to the Westernization of Eastern Europe. Chain stores, from Tower Records to Dunkin' Donuts, have staked claims to the Square, and in the process they threaten the distinctiveness that made it a landmark.

"Why destroy it? Why screw up one more unique piece of urban America?" says Pebble Gifford, a residential real estate agent who serves as president of the Harvard Square Defense Fund. "The developers want to leave it quite bland. And what always brought people to the Square was the quirkiness, the chance to see the crazies.

"We just feel so much is done in the name of the profit motive and the bottom line that is destructive," she adds. "There have to be other considerations."

Gifford's defense fund was for years able to hold off big developers by soliciting donations and using the money to sue, to petition, to print leaflets and to sue some more -- until the developers tired and went away.

But the old tactics now seem to be failing. Two major projects that could require the demolition of several historic buildings in the Square are being considered by the city government. And the end of rent control, brought on by a statewide referendum two years ago, is bringing rapid changes to the city, which sits on the opposite side of the Charles River from its larger and coarser sister, Boston.

In the Square, the lifting of rent control has fueled a rush of the wealthy into an area that had nurtured a mix of well-off professors, blue-collar workers and penniless grad students. The new construction has so homogenized the Square that Robert Campbell, architecture critic for the Boston Globe, has dismissively identified a "standard" new edifice for a site that used to be diverse: red brick, two stories high.

Many citizens in a city the Socialist Worker is still sold on street corners see these changes as nothing less than cataclysmic. Deepening the sense of gloom is the feeling that if small and eclectic can't survive here, they're dead everywhere.

A recent meeting of local neighborhood groups was entitled: "Harvard Square, an Endangered Species." A city councilwoman has been quoted as comparing the Square to the mall in an upscale Boston suburb. And at the nearby public high school, where Gov. William F. Weld sends his children, a group of students have formed the Harvard Square Liberation Front.

Harvard Square was settled in the 17th century, and its street pattern dates to that time. But history suggests that the Square's distinctiveness was lucky to have lasted as long as it did. It remained a unique outpost of odd-shaped buildings, tiny eateries and leftist literature, primarily because of the inattention of a Russian immigrant named Bertha Cohen.

From the early Depression until her death 20 years ago, Cohen owned about three dozen Square properties. Instead of consolidating and bringing in large projects, she offered low rents to merchants with dreams and little capital. But when she died, one developer snapped up all the properties, and proceeded to sell them off to -- of all people -- entrepreneurs interested in making lots of money.

The battles over the Square's character date back to the effort during the 1970s to place the John F. Kennedy presidential library along the Charles River. Residents beat back the library, but were soon under assault from developers who amassed adjacent properties and then tried to create larger stores.

Despite numerous defeats, the developers continued to make progress.

Gone are old-style eateries such as the German restaurant Wursthaus and the Mount Auburn Street sandwich shop Elsie's, where Edward M. Kennedy went after paying another Harvard undergraduate to take his Spanish exam. (Kennedy was caught and suspended). Now there are two Starbucks, with a third on the way.

Gone are two old discount record stores. Now there is giant HMV, 20,000 square feet of compact discs in a layered white building that skirts city height requirements, obscures views of the historic Brattle Theater (where Monday night is still Humphrey Bogart night) and is derisively called the "wedding cake".

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.