Republicans retreat from the 'revolution' With election looming, lawmakers cede gains for quiet end of term

Campaign 1996

September 30, 1996|By Karen Hosler | Karen Hosler,SUN NATIONAL STAFF

WASHINGTON -- In a painful retreat, Republicans who took over Congress two years ago and waged a crusade to shrink federal spending have given up some gains to reach a quiet end of their tumultuous term.

Badly bruised in budget battles with President Clinton that resulted in two government shutdowns last winter -- and facing stiff re-election challenges in many districts -- the Republicans have yielded to Clinton's demands to restore $6.5 billion in cuts to his pet programs as the price for a clean exit from Washington a month before November elections.

"Most of us don't agree with this, but we were afraid Clinton would shut down the government again and we would get blamed," said Rep. Wayne T. Gilchrest, a Republican from Maryland's Eastern Shore. "This whole thing these two years has been like passing a kidney stone."

As a further price for winning a budget deal with the White House before tonight, when most federal agencies would run out of money, the Republicans also made concessions on immigration policy and gun control, and might have to give up on a bill that would have expanded corporate sponsorship of national parks.

"They were frankly willing to pay a certain ransom to get out of town," David Mason, a congressional analyst for the Heritage Foundation, said of the GOP lawmakers. House members finished work on the final spending bill late Saturday; the Senate is expected to pass the measure today.

Republican leaders say that despite yielding to Clinton's demands for more spending on education, high technology, anti-terrorism, drug fighting and other priorities, they managed to save $53 billion in federal spending over the past two years.

But that savings total is disputed by Democrats and outside experts. What's more, it is chicken feed compared with the Republicans' ambitious attempt to squeeze nearly $1 trillion from federal spending in order to reach a balanced budget by 2002.

"Shrinking the government is like turning around a battleship: We didn't make any progress on that at all," said Sen. Pete V. Domenici, a New Mexico Republican who spent hundreds of hours last year crafting, passing and trying to get the White House to accept the balanced budget deal.

Even so, the first Republican-led Congress in four decades is heading home with a respectable list of accomplishments, most passed in a bipartisan blitz last summer, before lawmakers took a month off to campaign for re-election.

That period of productivity marked the beginning of the Republicans' willingness to make broad concessions to the White House in order to avoid being labeled a "do-nothing" Congress. At the same time, the Democrats were more willing to cooperate because GOP standard-bearer Bob Dole had just left his post as majority leader of the Senate, taking much of the tension of presidential politics with him.

The 60-year federal guarantee of welfare benefits was ended, and the program was turned over to the states to run. Depression-era farm subsidies are being phased out. A complex bill deregulating the communications industry also went through the GOP watch. And the president was given a power sought by many of his predecessors: a line-item veto enabling him to reject individual items in spending bills.

"You asked for real change in 1994," House Speaker Newt Gingrich, leader of what he once called the Republican "revolution," told a GOP rally on the Capitol steps last week. "We kept our word."

But congressional Democrats, who spent months in shock at their sudden relegation to minority status last year, can barely control their glee at the Republicans' reversal of fortune.

They are particularly amused that the GOP includes among its accomplishments a bill expanding access to health insurance coverage that was largely the handiwork of Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, a Massachusetts Democrat.

In fact, Kennedy, the longtime poster boy for liberal politics, scored one of his most productive sessions ever under the Republicans, with victories that included a boost in the minimum wage, which GOP leaders originally had resisted.

"You can stand on the Capitol steps and hire a brass band and blow up a lot of balloons, but you still can't make a full-scale retreat look like a full-dress parade," said Senate Minority Leader Tom Daschle, a South Dakota Democrat. "The only time the Republican Congress worked was when they let the Democrats lead."

Congressional Republicans clearly took on a bigger challenge than they could manage with only a slender majority in the House, too few senators to block Democratic filibusters and a Democrat in the White House.

Driven by 73 confident but somewhat naive freshmen, the Republicans were buoyed by their early success in passing through the House nearly all of the items in their "Contract with America," a 1994 campaign document that they turned into a blueprint for governing.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.