Huge First Union aims to be Wal-Mart of banking

June 25, 1995|By Timothy J. Mullaney | Timothy J. Mullaney,Sun Staff Writer

In the past few years, millions of Northerners have learned to shop at Wal-Mart.

In the end, First Union Corp.'s announcement Monday that it will acquire First Fidelity Bancorp. for $5.4 billion is a bet that Baltimore, New Jersey and Philadelphia will learn to love banking at Wal-Mart, too -- figuratively, that is.

The merger is the latest wave of consolidation that is sweeping banking nationwide, and which analysts expect to put a hard squeeze in the next few years on midsized banks like those that have traditionally served Baltimore.

The big players will be much bigger, using their size to drive costs down and gobble up smaller competitors.

Like the Arkansas retailing giant, they will use their money to buy superior technology, more savvy marketing, and a broader menu of ways to help customers save and invest that blurs the traditional line between Main Street and Wall Street finance. And they are supposed to crush the Signet Banking Corporations and Provident Banks of Maryland of the world like so many small-town dime stores.

First Union's chairman, Edward E. Crutchfield, and its president, John R. Georgius, believe their bank will be among the biggest of them all, shedding its reputation as a once-sleepy bank in Charlotte, N.C.

"What we've been trying to create is a bank that looks two-thirds like a traditional bank and one-third like a Merrill Lynch," Mr. Georgius said. And, he admits, a little like Wal-Mart.

"I'd say it's very close to that," he said. "We spend a lot of time on details."

U.S. banking has always been shaped as much by the law as by economics. Compared to other nations, the U.S. has many more banks because laws prevented banks from operating in more than one state.

And banks couldn't do as much for customers as their foreign counterparts, because of Depression-era laws keeping banks out of the securities business.

In 1973, Mr. Crutchfield became president of First Union Bank of North Carolina at the age of 32. The bank, then about the size of today's Farmers National Bancorp in Annapolis, is what it is because Mr. Crutchfield saw in the early 1980s how the laws were changing.

He was particularly struck by a 1985 Supreme Court decision allowing interstate banking prohibitions to be gradually lifted.

"I had talked to Crutchfield before that [court decision] and he didn't think it would go through," said John J. Mason, an analyst who follows First Union for Interstate/Johnson Lane in Atlanta. .. "But he told me that if it did, he would have to cross state lines and buy the biggest thing he could. Theoretically, if you waited too long, someone else would grab the best thing left."

So away Mr. Crutchfield went. In 1985, First Union had $8 billion in assets, making it smaller than First Maryland Bancorp is today. By last year, it was $77.3 billion.

And when the last of the interstate banking limits go off the books in September, First Union will be even freer to make acquisitions.

Anthony Davis, a Dean Witter analyst, points out that these same restrictions helped protect First Union's turf in the southeast from bigger rivals, such as Banc One Corp. of Columbus, Ohio, and BankAmerica Corp. of San Francisco.

"By the time we got to 1984, we knew what we had to do," said Georgius, who said First Union thought $25 billion in assets would be big enough to preserve its independence. "We had to prepare either to be sold, to try to grow, or to do nothing. We made a decision we were going to try [to grow]. What we didn't realize was it was going to take a lot more."

So many mergers were being perused that Mr. Georgius took over First Union's day-to-day operations to enable his boss Mr. Crutchfield to pursue deal-making full-time.

The deals started small -- a $3.6 billion bank in Florida, a $2.6 billion company in North Carolina, and a flurry of banks as small as $35 million in assets.

The biggest deals began with two Florida takeovers in 1990 and 1991 when First Union took in $19 billion in assets, followed by four Virginia banks with assets totaling $17.5 billion.

First Union's stock has produced a total return approaching 200 percent over the past five years, outperforming the Standard & Poor major regional bank index, which returned 78 percent over the same period, and rival NationsBank Corp., whose stock returned 65 percent.

First Union's stock hit a 52-week high of $50.625 earlier this month but lost ground on news of last week's First Fidelity deal, closing Friday at $45.25, up 25 cents.

The latest of 59 acquisitions, the First Fidelity purchase will make First Union the nation's sixth-biggest bank, allowing it to expand into New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Delaware.

It will have nearly 2,000 branches, including the 63 in Maryland it bought from First Fidelity. (First Fidelity moved into the state only last year by buying the Bank of Baltimore and agreeing to take over branches of Household Bank and the defunct John Hanson Savings and Loan.)

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.