Ghosts from NASA's temper hopes for Hubble

December 12, 1993|By Frank D. Roylance | Frank D. Roylance,Staff Writer

The Endeavour astronauts wowed everyone last week as they wrestled and coaxed the Hubble Space Telescope back to good health. But for the mission's top scientists, last week's heady success is tempered by caution and the ghosts of NASA's past '' failures.

"It is extremely difficult to keep from getting excited right now," said senior Hubble scientist Dr. David Leckrone, "but I've got to try.

"Hubble's just had eye surgery," he explained. "We think it was successful, but we're not going to know for sure until we're able to take the bandages off."

Unwrapping the bandages will take 15 weeks and occupy hundreds of scientists and engineers at the Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt and at Baltimore's Space Telescope Science Institute.

It is painstaking work, carried out at computer keyboards in windowless rooms. By remote control, Hubble's handlers must gradually nudge its mirrors into place, seeking a precise configuration that delivers the sharpest possible image to the telescope's cameras and spectrographs.

An apt analogy is the way in which a photographer turns the focusing ring on a camera -- first one way, then the other -- until the image of the subject appears sharp.

"It's a very delicate process," said NASA's Hubble program scientist, Dr. Edward J. Weiler. "I can't guarantee success. We've done everything humanly possible to make this succeed."

The process is the same one engineers were working through in June 1990 when they came to the awful conclusion that there was no single configuration of mirrors that could bring the heavens into sharp focus.

Their $1.5 billion space telescope had been launched with a primary mirror ground to the wrong prescription. They later learned that a NASA contractor had ignored test results in 1981 that warned of such a problem.

In many ways, Hubble remained the world's premier astronomical observatory, especially in ultraviolet wavelengths. But scientists concluded that without repairs it could never fulfill its promise to reveal the faintest, oldest and most distant secrets the universe.

With the mirror blunder flashing like neon in their heads, NASA officials vowed this time to ensure the performance of the hardware built to correct Hubble's blurred vision.

Independent review panel

NASA created an independent review panel chaired by Dr. Duncan Moore, a professor of optics at the University of Rochester. Its job was to look at all the work by the many groups that were analyzing Hubble's mirror flaw and designing and building mirrors to correct it.

Everything NASA and its contractors did was reviewed and verified with multiple, independently developed tests.

This time, "we certainly expect everything will be OK," said Dr. Kenneth G. Carpenter, project scientist for operations and ground systems at Goddard. "But everyone is and will be tense, and no one will breathe easily until we get confirmation down that the instruments all work."

Most encouraging to scientists were tests using simulators that generated light bent to Hubble's blurred prescription.

The simulators' light was beamed through the new Wide Field/Planetary Camera and COSTAR, the mirrors that Endeavour astronauts installed to deliver corrected images to three other Hubble instruments.

"And sure enough, we got extremely sharp images, essentially perfect images," said Dr. George Hartig, an optical systems scientist at the space telescope institute.

The focusing work that will spell the success or failure of Hubble's repairs is to begin in two weeks, after Goddard engineers finish tuning up Hubble's guidance systems, including its star trackers and the newly installed gyroscopes.

Focusing will be made easier by more freely adjustable mirrors in the new instruments.

The first job will be to adjust the Wide Field/Planetary Camera's "pickoff" mirror, to make sure it can capture light gathered by the telescope's 94-inch primary mirror and 12-inch secondary mirror, and reflect that into the camera.

Next, scientists will make coarse focusing adjustments with Hubble's secondary mirror, which was not involved in last week's repairs.

"We'll take a series of images with the secondary mirror moved in 9-micron steps, then look at the sequence and find out where it's sharpest," said Dr. Carpenter. A micron is equal to one thousandth of a millimeter, or .000039 inch.

Five weeks from now, after making similar adjustments to an internal "fold" mirror, scientists will begin fine focusing the Wide Field/Planetary Camera, tweaking the telescope's secondary mirror again.

"We'll do this for six orbits . . . take the data and work on it for a week, then see if we need more data," Dr. Carpenter said.

Initial pictures from the Wide Field/Planetary Camera are planned for release after seven weeks.

'First light' pictures

These "first light" pictures will include distant galaxies, star clusters and faint objects in fields of bright stars -- chosen to show off Hubble's better vision. Photos taken before the repairs are expected to be fuzzy in comparison.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.