Keeping careful track of Lionel trains' value


November 21, 1993|By Lita Solis-Cohen and Sally Solis-Cohen | Lita Solis-Cohen and Sally Solis-Cohen,Contributing Writers Solis-Cohen Enterprises

Q: How do I find out about old electric Lionel trains? My set, purchased in 1938, is in good running condition and has its original box and instructions. Is it valuable?

A: Condition, age, rarity and demand help determine how much collectors might pay for a set of old Lionel trains, according to Ron Hollander, 197 Lincoln Ave., Newark, N.J. 07104. He is author of "All Aboard! The Story of Joshua Lionel Cowen & His Toy Train Company," ($14.95 paperback, Workman Publishing). He says your circa 1936-'41 "Commodore Vanderbilt" set, named for the founder of the New York Central Railroad, is a common model, worth around $200.

The most sought-after Lionel models generally predate World War II and are "in as close to the same condition they were on Christmas, when trembling 6-year-old fingers unwrapped them," says Mr. Hollander, noting that extremely rare sets in their original boxes and with their original gift wrap can bring premium prices. A Standard Gauge (2 1/8 inches wide from rail-to-rail) Depression-era Blue Comet steam engine with three passenger cars, which sold for $75 new, today can zoom up to around $4,000, depending on condition.

Rare models painted in unusual colors also are high-ticket items. An original 1957 pink Lady Lionel passenger train, a commercial failure when new, cruises in at up to about $1,000. It's one of the many Lionel sets which have been reissued, so buying from a knowledgeable and reliable dealer who guarantees authenticity is important.

Serious model-train collectors belong to the Train Collectors Association, P.O. Box 248, Strasburg, Pa. 17579, (717) 687-8623, which publishes a newsletter, organizes shows and operates a toy-train museum. There's a $25 application fee to join, plus annual dues of $20.

Ted Mauer Auctions, 1003 Brookwood Drive, Pottstown, Pa. 19464-3022, (215) 323-1573, specializes in toy trains and regularly sells Lionels.

Q: Since it's the 30th anniversary of President John F. Kennedy's assassination, I was curious about the value of an autographed menu I have from his 45th birthday celebration on May 19, 1962, at the Four Seasons restaurant in New York.

A: Assuming the JFK autograph is authentic, and not the handiwork of a secretary, your menu could be worth $600 to $900 if in good condition, according to autograph and manuscript dealer Joseph Rubinfine, 505 S. Flagler Drive, Suite 1301, West Palm Beach, Fla. 33401, (407) 659-7077. A U.S. Senate restaurant menu signed by Kennedy brought $525 at auction recently, Mr. Rubinfine says, noting that collectors probably would pay a bit more for a JFK signature dating from his White House years. After Lincoln, Washington and Jefferson, Kennedy's is among the most sought-after presidential signatures.

Other readers have asked about an almost mint-condition copy of "A Tour of the White House with Mrs. John F. Kennedy," published by Perry Wolff/Doubleday, in 1962, and autographed by the first lady (worth about $500 if the signature is genuine, and under $25 unsigned, according to dealer Catherine Barnes, of Philadelphia). A first edition of JFK's "Profiles in Courage," which won a Pulitzer Prize in 1957, can fetch $1,200 to $1,500, if it has a genuine Kennedy inscription and is in good condition, Ms. Barnes adds.

At a Sotheby's manuscript auction in New York this month, an autographed 1960 six-page offprint of the August 1944 Reader's Digest condensation of John Hersey's "Survival" article from the New Yorker, celebrating Kennedy's exploits after the sinking of PT-109 during World War II, fetched $5,750. Issued in Boston by the Massachusetts Committee for John F. Kennedy for President, the copy was signed by Kennedy for the consignor during a Charleston, W.Va., campaign stop in the summer of 1960.


Have a question about an antique or collectible? Write to the Solis-Cohens, P.O. Box 304, Flourtown, Pa. 19031-0304, enclosing a clear photo of the whole object and all marks. Photos can't be returned. Although personal replies are not possible, questions of general interest will be answered in this column.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.