Criminals like Westley Allan Dodd can't be saved

Andrew Vachss

January 06, 1993|By Andrew Vachss

WESTLEY Allan Dodd was hung just after midnight yesterda at the Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla.

Sentenced to execution for the torture-murder of three boys, Dodd refused all efforts to appeal his case.

He may not have exhausted his legal remedies, but he certainly exhausted society's efforts at "rehabilitation."

A chronic, calcified sexual sadist, Dodd stated in a recent court brief, "If I do escape, I promise you I will kill and rape again and I will enjoy every minute of it."

Dodd's threat is now erased, but there can be no dispute that other monsters live among us. The only question is what to do with them once they become known to us.

The death penalty is not a response. Racially and economically biased and endlessly protracted, it returns little for its enormous economic and social costs. Though it is effective -- the killer will not strike again -- the death penalty is limited to murderers; it will not protect us from rapists and child molesters who are virtually assured of release and who are almost certain to commit their crimes again.

If we do not intend to execute sex criminals, does our hope lie in killing their destructive impulses?

Dodd and his ilk are sociopaths. They are characterized by a fundamental lack of empathy. All children are born pure egoists. They perceive their needs to the exclusion of all others. Only through socialization do they learn that some forms of gratification must be deferred and others denied.

When a child's development is incomplete or perverted -- and child abuse is the most dominant cause in that equation -- he or she tends not to develop empathy. There's a missing card, one that cannot be put back in the deck once the personality is fully formed.

While early childhood experiences may impel, they do not compel. In the end, evil is a matter of choice.

Sociopaths can learn to project a veneer of civilization -- for predators, it is part of their camouflage -- but they will always lack the ability to feel any pain but their own, pursuing only self-gratification.

Not all sociopaths choose sexual violence. For some, the outlet can be political or economic skulduggery. But those for whom blood or pain is the stimulus act no less efficiently and at a terrible and unacceptable cost.

Some predatory sociopaths can be deterred. None can be rehabilitated because they cannot return to a state that never existed. The concept of coercive therapy is a contradiction; successful psychiatric treatment requires participants, not mere recipients.

What makes sexual predators so intractable and dangerous is that, as Dodd candidly acknowledged, they like what they do and intend to keep doing it.

The obsession of sexual predators is typified in the case of Donald Chapman, a New Jersey rapist who was released in November after serving 12 years, the maximum for his crime.

He underwent continual therapy in prison and was utterly unaffected by it. He vows to continue to attack women -- a threat that reflects his total absorption with sexual torture. As a result of his threat, he sits in his house in Wyckoff, N.J., surrounded by a 24-hour police guard.

A 1992 study of 767 rapists and child molesters in Minnesota found those who completed psychiatric treatment were arrested more often for new sex crimes than those who had not been treated at all. A Canadian survey that tracked released child molesters in Minnesota found those who completed psychiatric treatment were arrested more often for new sex crimes than those who had not been treated at all. A Canadian survey that tracked released child molesters for 20 years revealed child molesters for 20 years revealed a 43 percent recidivism rate regardless of the therapy. The difference between those simply incarcerated and those subjected to a full range of treatments appears statistically negligible. And the more violent and sadistic the offense, the more likely it is to be repeated.

Another factor that thwarts rehabilitation is the need for offenders to seek higher and higher levels of stimulation. There is no observable waning of their desires over time: Sexual predators do not outgrow their behavior. Thus, while most sadistic sex offenders are not first arrested for homicide, they may well try to murder someone in the future.

What about a traditional self-help program? Should we concentrate on raising self-esteem? Imprisoned predators receive as much fan mail as rock stars. They are courted by the news media, studied by devoted sociologists, their every word treasured as though profound. Their paintings are collected, their poetry published. Trading cards celebrate their bloody passage among us.

I recently received a letter from a young woman who gushed that, after a long exchange of letters, she was "granted visiting privileges" with Dodd and subsequently appeared on "Sally Jessy Raphael" "due to my relationship" with "Wes," who she believes is "sincere." So do I. We simply disagree about the object of his sincerity.

Baltimore Sun Articles
|
|
|
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.