Bush ends ban on trade with South Africa Executive order tied to 'profound' moves on apartheid

July 11, 1991|By Peter Honey | Peter Honey,Washington Bureau of The Sun

WASHINGTON -- President Bush swept aside the centerpiece of U.S. trade and investment sanctions against South Africa yesterday, saying the country's black and white leaders had made "profound" and "irreversible" progress toward ending apartheid and preparing for negotiations on a new non-racial democracy.

Mr. Bush said he was convinced -- against protests and rebuttals from several key Democrats and black leaders -- that the white minority government had complied with the five conditions necessary for him to lift the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act. Congress enacted the measure over a veto by then-President Ronald Reagan in October 1986.

President Bush said he issued an executive order shortly before noon terminating the act and lifting bans on a variety of South African imports and exports, financial and commercial investments and bank loans.

In addition, aides said, the U.S. Treasury was expected to act shortly on a State Department recommendation to lift a 1988 amendment that doubled the tax load on U.S. firms in South Africa.

The United States, Mr. Bush said, would strive also to help the South African economy out of its economic decline. The administration has decided to double its annual assistance to black South Africans from $40 million to $80 million for housing, economic development and education.

"This is a moment in history which many believed would never be attained," Mr. Bush said.

However, he added, "All is not totally well there, and we will

continue to be actively involved -- as actively involved as we can be."

The president said he would appeal to the leading industrial nations at their London summit next week to follow suit. "We all must help now," he said.

"Progress has been slow and often painful," Mr. Bush said of change in racial laws in South Africa. "But progress has definitely been made."

He disclosed that he had spoken earlier by telephone with anti-apartheid leader Nelson Mandela to tell him that lifting sanctions was "the right thing to do" and to inform him of the enhanced assistance program. He said that he would personally telephone South African President F. W. de Klerk today and that he would "indicate to him, we expect progress to continue."

Mr. Mandela told Mr. Bush that he disagreed with the lifting of sanctions, Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs

Herman Cohen said at a briefing later.

"He felt it was premature . . . that the process of dismantling apartheid hadn't proceeded as far as it should have," Mr. Cohen said.

That view was echoed by U.S. anti-apartheid activists and several prominent Democrats, some of whom said they were considering challenging the president's action in court.

In Houston, NAACP Executive Director Benjamin L. Hooks said the move was "criminally irresponsible."

"I'm not satisfied" that the South African government has released all its political prisoners, said House Speaker Thomas S. Foley, D-Wash. "The most important element -- political rights -- has not been achieved."

The anti-apartheid act listed five conditions the South African government would have to meet before sanctions could be lifted -- including one mandatory condition, the release of all political prisoners.

South Africa has reportedly released more than 1,500 political prisoners over the last eight months. More than 850 are still in prisons and jails, but the State Department accepts the South African government's position that these are people guilty of political violence -- considered criminal -- and that they do not therefore warrant release.

Mr. Bush lifted the sanctions after receiving assurances from Secretary of State James A. Baker III that "all persons persecuted for their political beliefs or detained unduly without trial" had been freed, administration officials said.

The State Department said previously that the four other conditions had been met.

Sen. Claiborne Pell, D-R.I., chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said he did not believe that South Africa had released all political prisoners.

"Continued pressure is necessary . . . to ensure that further progress is made toward the goal of achieving full political, economic and social equality," he said.

He favored a partial lifting of the sanctions: "The administration has done too much too soon," he said.

Republican Sen. Richard G. Lugar of Indiana, however, who as chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee in 1986 sponsored the anti-apartheid bill, supported the president yesterday, saying that the movement toward democracy in South Africa was "irreversible."

The dispute hinges on interpretations of the conditions. Gay McDougall, a director of the Washington-based Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights Under the Law, said her organization was studying the possibility of challenging the president's decision in court. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, D-Mass., hinted at similar action last month while delivering an appeal for the president not to lift the sanctions.

Baltimore Sun Articles
Please note the green-lined linked article text has been applied commercially without any involvement from our newsroom editors, reporters or any other editorial staff.